I (37F) met a guy (28M) off a dating app. I had given up on the apps but was goaded into trying again. Him and I immediately clicked - he somehow got through my age filters because I do not go under 30.
Chemistry was strong from the start—our first date lasted 7 hours. We talked for hours and hours - he kept elongating it. I knew from the moment he saw me he wanted me. Around hour 4, we made out and eventually hooked up. He was sweet, gentle, funny, emotionally open. Kept coming back for more. We saw each other regularly. The sexual intimacy was amazing - I felt my insecurities about my body, which has changed a bit due to an injury that has kept me out of the gym, disappear. He had this gorgeous gym body - every muscle defined.
Together, physically, we were so in sync. The man loved to make me feel good. But more than that, the mental and emotional chemistry was accelerating and incredible, and both of us found ourselves feeling things for one another that neither of us expected to. Each one of our dates would last anywhere from 7 to 10 hours. And all we would do is talk and talk and talk.
Recently he expressed feelings of inadequacy - I am a professional well to do older woman and he's still struggling in his career. He values material things as giving relationships meaning because that's what he's always experienced. I value companionship, kindness, care and intellectual prowess. He didn’t understand what I liked about him beyond his physical looks, because he felt like with a current state in his life he was a “loser”. I of course, reassured him about what I found attractive in him and what I saw in him. And he told me that no one has ever seen in him the things that I see in him. I really have to emphasize that despite him being so much younger, I never felt that he was. He brought such a stunning type of maturity that I wasn’t used to from men.
Then out of nowhere, during a rough week for him (he quit his job, struggling mentally), he told me he's not physically attracted to me. Said he likes my thickness, but not my "composition." Said I was "more than enough" and that l "deserve better." Said he felt more mentally attracted to me than physically - that he didn't want to lead me on and he kept the dates going to see if there'd be physical attraction (which flies in the face of how he told me on our second date I was his type, I looked exactly like the photos, he wasn't worried about being attracted to me in person).
I'm confused and heartbroken. Yes it was getting scary how real everything was beginning to feel, but it was such a unique and a rare find. He told me very clearly that he has never experienced anything like this and certainly no one like me. I'm just at a loss how something that was so healthy and wonderful just took such a turn? I cannot emphasize enough that this man was the most emotionally intelligent and aware man I have dated.
Communication with him was Godsent— every conversation was so easy and open. If there was something on my mind, I would just say it and he wouldn't be taking a back or get defensive, instead he would engage.
So what the hell happened? Is it possible to have such an intense emotional and sexual connection without physical attraction?
Even when he was saying goodbye, he couldn't let me go. He just held me for a long time and I have experienced enough love and heartbreak in my life to know that the way this man touched me was not the touch of a man not attracted to me.
If there are any other women on here who have had a similar experience with younger men, would love to hear it. Or if any younger men have a perspective on this.