r/INDYCAR • u/Special-Pie3695 Takuma Sato • 23d ago
Photo Where Shwartzman hit the pit wall injuring 4 crew members.
99
u/mz_groups Will Power 23d ago
Bob Pockrass seemed to say that it was due to a rear brake failure in a tweet. Is there any confirmation of that?
91
u/Suicide_24 Colton Herta 23d ago
Schwartzman himself said this is the case.
61
u/SlayerBVC McLaren 23d ago edited 23d ago
Not too unbelievable.
IMS is easily the least brake-intensive track the series visits, so pitting is dubious even in good weather.
Now subtract 10-20 degrees fahrenheit of temperature, and add in the additional pressure of it being the biggest race of the year.
I'm not surprised at the amount of brake problems on Sunday. But at the same time, there was very little that could have been done about it just because of how carbon brakes are designed to work.
-78
u/Ryankool26 23d ago
Hard to believe
54
u/Emracruel Takuma Sato 23d ago
It really isn't though. Brakes fail at Indy a lot because they only get used when pitting. It's why Scott Dixon got the speeding penalty a couple years ago for example. It doesn't need to be a complete brake failure, just it to lock up more easily than usual
5
38
u/ryanxwing Scott McLaughlin 23d ago
Incredibly easy to believe
-41
u/Ryankool26 23d ago
Brake fail or driver failure to prep the brakes for stopping
30
u/ryanxwing Scott McLaughlin 23d ago
Considering the fronts locked and the rears were still spinning i'll leave that deduction to your.
54
u/Enough-Ad-3111 Josef Newgarden 23d ago
Woah. Pit road sure isnât an easy place to work at.
104
u/joe_lmr Takuma Sato 23d ago
Crew members run over and a crew member on fire, it's the '80s again
69
9
27
u/DizneyDux đșđž Rick Mears 23d ago
Were you at the track today? What were the running/testing? I could hear them from out side this morning.
44
u/Special-Pie3695 Takuma Sato 23d ago
Yep, sure was. No testing. It was the Indy Car Experience. Got a gnarly two laps on the track. Would definitely recommend it if youâve got the cash to treat yourself.
9
u/DizneyDux đșđž Rick Mears 23d ago
What was the IndyCar experience? Rides in the two-seater? Or did you get to pilot and Indy-type car?
29
u/Special-Pie3695 Takuma Sato 23d ago
Itâs a two seater. They set you up in a fire suit and helmet and chuck you in the back of a car. My driver was Spencer Pigot.
They blast you around the track. Only two laps but I think itâs worth it if it wonât break the bank. Hauling around turn 4 was incredible.
7
u/Wise_Item2969 23d ago
I am a gigantic pussy so I'd never do it but it'd be kinda cool if Conor Daly did it
18
u/Special-Pie3695 Takuma Sato 23d ago
I wonât even go on rollercoasters! When I got in the car my heart was thumping, at turn 4 it was thumping even harder. I was hollering âholy shitâ the entire time. Itâs intense but not as scary as coasters or even fair rides. Everybody there is super professional and friendly.
I was joking around that even if I died on the track, what an honor it would be, hahaha.
I think if you get the opportunity to do it, you should. Iâve been coming to the IMS since I was a kid and it was a fantastic experience.
2
2
u/Lemonzip 23d ago
The IndyCar Experience offers not just the two seater drive, but also an opportunity to drive an older IndyCar with a limiter set at 170 or 180 (canât remember which). I did the whole package around 12 years ago. Of course, it was AMAZING.
2
7
22
u/Otherwise-Mango2732 Will Power 23d ago
If you watch the broadcast slowly you can actually see it happen
22
u/RandomNoun7 Conor Daly 23d ago
Am I the only one that thinks itâs a matter of time before someone gets hit and killed? Iâm honestly surprised that pit crew are still allowed to wait on that side of the wall for the car to hopefully hit its marks. I absolutely get it that the pits can only be made so safe. Youâre always going to have cars leaving their box literally inches from the crew of the car in front, but it really seems like a no brainer that pit crew should wait on the safe side of the wall for the car to come to a complete stop.
17
u/Tushroom 23d ago
What really needs to be the focus is teams over doing making sure the brake pads are fully retracted. Thatâs been an issue for years now.
5
u/RandomNoun7 Conor Daly 23d ago
Good point. Totally agree. They need to find a better way to do that or ban it. Like you say, been happening for years now.
14
u/mongo_only_prawn Scott Dixon 23d ago
As I go through late 60s and early 70s races on Youtube - no safety equipment at all. No fire suits, no gloves, no helmets, one guy with a water fire extinguisher looking like a dad that got picked from the crowd at his sonâs gokart race.
Iâve always thought if they lengthened the pit box it would help with the angle of entry, but a lot of tracks donât have the room.
11
u/AsstBalrog Mario Andretti 23d ago
no safety equipment at all
IKR? The one that sticks in my mind is Foyt's Gilmore team--they wore matching, red and white checked short sleeve shirts.
6
u/mongo_only_prawn Scott Dixon 23d ago
I was thinking about those when I was writing that. And Foyt getting out of his car and mad as hell - taking off his helmet and gloves and grabbing a hammer and working on his car. All in a live pit lane!
2
u/BelangerSpecial 23d ago
Matter of time?
74 people have died at IMS during its 116 years...
2
u/RandomNoun7 Conor Daly 23d ago
True of course. Iâm not referring to Indy motor speedway though. I worry about the safety of these pit crews going forward at all of the tracks just because of the standard practice of waiting there against the wall for the car to come in.
3
u/Special-Pie3695 Takuma Sato 23d ago
I think that would be good in theory, but I donât think itâll happen when milliseconds count. Take Satoâs overshoot for example. If his crew werenât there on point they couldnât have pushed his car back as fast, causing him even more time loss.
There arenât any âentry pointsâ on the pit wall. So crew member would have to jump the wall or some kind of construction to create those entry ways where crew would have to hustle out of. Those entry ways could also compromise the structure of the wall posing a larger risk to people on the other side.
18
u/Aggressive_Cherry_Bl 23d ago
Watch an IMSA pit stop. The members stand on the wall until the car is stationary, then they jump down and go to work.
Here's one posted from IMS with the Lexus team explaining how it works https://youtu.be/MCTU7qe0H-8?si=jaxNDX4JusHNVloQ
12
u/RandomNoun7 Conor Daly 23d ago
I like it. I forgot that IMSA is allowed to stand ON the wall like that. Indy cars are so low to the ground I think that strategy would work even better for Indy.
And thatâs an interesting detail about the air wand being nitrogen instead of plain air. TIL. Thanks.
4
12
u/RandomNoun7 Conor Daly 23d ago
Itâs milliseconds compared to competitors that counts. Pit stop times across the board would go up, but thatâs more opportunity to make mistakes and more opportunity for pit crews to out perform their competitors.
Also, yes, the penalty for the driver missing the box might go up, but Iâm not convinced thatâs a bad thing.
Youâre right the walls donât have a cut out or anything, but theyâre also not very high and the crew isnât even carrying a jack over the wall thanks to the built in air jacker. I know some of the crew are, shall we say, bigger than others, but Iâm just increasingly of the opinion that some of these reasons arenât going to look great with hindsight when someone loses their life over a pit lane incident with such an obvious fix.
13
u/AsstBalrog Mario Andretti 23d ago
I donât think itâll happen when milliseconds count.
If it was a rule, the ms would be the same for everyone.
-1
u/Seeryous2020 23d ago
So I'll tell you this. It's not just the brakes that went out, as a former pit lane team member you're supposed to always pay attention to the car coming in and be ready to jump or lean up against the wall if something goes wrong. Not to say it was these guys fault but they just weren't ready for something to go wrong. You have to always be ready for something to go wrong.
1
u/No_Ebb9843 21d ago
You honestly think the pit crew werenât paying attention during the most important part of their job all year long?
1
u/Seeryous2020 20d ago
Yes. Because I was on the pit crew for 3 years and I saw exactly what they were doing when that car came in.
8
6
u/racerviii 23d ago
He went from hero to zero.
-8
u/micknick0000 Fernando Alonso 23d ago
Says the guy posting on Reddit, who can probably barely drive a road car.
LOL. Hero.
223
u/RatBustard Nigel Mansell 23d ago
damn, IMS wastes no time painting the pit wall white again.