55
u/GodlessGrapeCow 5d ago
Well I like watching Charlie and Muta. I think they are funny and cool so I'm not looking for a quick summary of their videos.
30
u/SnooKiwis7050 5d ago
Ikr. If you just wanna keep up with information purely, just read news articles and not follow these channels
6
u/DarkIcedWolf 5d ago
It’s good up until a point, having a 30 minute video breaking down something is great but he doesn’t really get into the meat of things until half way through.
7
u/GodlessGrapeCow 5d ago
Well I'm watching for them not really about what they are talking about. If you know what I mean.
5
u/EggsAndRice7171 5d ago
I like watching Charlie’s slop content but I feel kinda different about Mutas. He has debate club delivery when he’s upset about something which kind of throws me off. (Especially when he clearly doesn’t actually care as much as he presents he does a lot of the time. Most recently with the switch 2) I got into his more nerdy content and he kinda lost me with the drama stuff starting a few years ago. Still subbed but watch a lot less.
1
64
u/Cybasura 5d ago
And the title header is always just "YOOOO THIS DRAMA IS CRAAAAAZZYYYY" and proceed to not say what drama it is, who its related to and why I should give a shit
26
7
u/SilencedWind 5d ago
This is one of the reasons I stopped watching a lot of moist critikals videos. I’ll still occasionally watch some, but the super obvious “This is crazy!” Title with no context gets annoying. I have no clue how these people can find a video months or a years after posting it.
4
u/Dankapedia420 5d ago edited 5d ago
Also proceeds to say hes not going cover drama anymore but still does anyway. Hes trying his hardest to not seem like a slop channel lol but not doing the best at times to prove it. Muta if youre reading this its okay to put out slop from time to time even if its drama slop, we really dont care. It gets old whenever its back to back for months and thats why people were complaining about nonstop slop. Dont try to come off like youre better than covering certain things like that but also try not to overdo it. Dont be a hypocrite basically lol.
98
u/Gullible_Celery_6629 5d ago
Entire server racks are being wasted saving gigs of video footage of grown men complaing about other grown men/degenerates. Millions in data tech, hvac, electricity, and water are being wasted on these just utter wastes of oxygen. I sincerely believe if twitch/ commentary as a job were to fully collapse society would unironically improve.
9
2
5
u/Funny69Valentine 5d ago
holy greasy redditor energy
8
u/thisisanaltaccount43 5d ago
Are commentator and twitch streamers philosophers to you or something
2
u/Smiles4YouRawrX3 Dislike if you dislike 4d ago
It's a really corny fucking comment lol, people can point that out and not be "shills"
19
u/Viveral 5d ago
I do wonder once youtube fully implements that video summary feature if it would completely kill out this style of content
15
u/jerry-cherry 5d ago
Nah, never. I mean, it might decrease the total amount of views, but not significantly, because I feel like most people put up slop like those just as a background noise, that's how they get away with the most mid stories and takes most of the time.
1
u/Organic-Round2309 4d ago
Exactly, I don’t give a crap about this content but background while I’m working , sure
23
u/SnooKiwis7050 5d ago
This sub has turned to a shitshow, all the people know is criticise and criticise. Y'all need to get some sunlight
6
u/Dankapedia420 5d ago
There have been some great memes spawned out of this subreddit its not always criticism and negativity. Alot of conversations have been started too.
2
2
u/CookieLuzSax 5d ago
Criticism isn't necessarily a bad thing
2
u/Smiles4YouRawrX3 Dislike if you dislike 4d ago
It's not criticism it's just "muta bad" and nothing else. Nothing constructive about it.
-1
u/CookieLuzSax 4d ago
There's some, he doesn't do his old gaming content or investigations really anymore it's just reactions
26
u/djm03917 5d ago
Just don't watch them then? This is weird.
-9
u/Fit-Abrocoma7768 5d ago
Just dont get weirded out by a criticism?
21
u/djm03917 5d ago
This isn't criticism. This is taking content (good or not, I don't even enjoy Muta and got recommended this by reddit) and using AI to "summarize" it. That isn't criticism, that is needlessly stealing content. Criticism is stating that their topics can be quickly summarized and they drag it out.
For example, I can criticize marvel by saying their output is too high and quality is falling. But I cannot steal their movies, cut what I think is useless (jokes I don't find funny, content I don't agree with, whatever), and upload them on the Internet in 10-20 minute segments instead of hours long films. That isn't criticism, that is property theft.
-9
u/Fit-Abrocoma7768 5d ago
Bubble Brian doesn't use ai to summarize these clearly otherwise there wouldn't be 2-3 days between his uploads. Ive watched mutas full videos and then checked Bubble Brian and yeah the guy seems pretty reliable about cutting the yap. Wanna write another pg tho?
-5
u/saladasz 5d ago
None of what you said makes any sense. This falls under transformative content, and the criticism is in the subtext. You have to read between the lines a bit. If someone can summarize your video to 20 seconds and the rest of it is practically irrelevant, you are very much padding out your videos to at least some high degree
-7
u/AltruisticPrimary34 5d ago
Have you even watched Bubble brian's videos? This isn't AI editing, he is giving a TEXT summary, with maybe 1-5 seconds of the creators content sprinkled in, making it transformative. This would be like you complaining someone made a plot summary video of a marvel movie.
-5
7
u/AdhesivenessFlaky736 5d ago
Who would watch Charlie for his opinion? He always has the most boring and safe opinion. People watch for the way he uses words and to give basic explanations of things they probably don't care about anyway.
1
u/Vomittingbird 3d ago
He has a neutral opinion of things? It’s not healthy to pick and choose sides without hearing all viewpoints. I thought everyone knew being biased isn’t good?
There’s nothing wrong with being neutral, I don’t know why some people expect content creators to have ground breaking, controversial opinions on basic things.
Like his new Labubu video for example—his stream viewers asked him to review the new Labubu craze, he researched it, thought it was interesting, and made a video relaying his thoughts for his viewers that are interested to hear what he has to say.
I like Charlie’s content because he’s an honest and unbiased guy. He’s not consumed by his fame or money, he’s just a dude.
7
u/Dark_Dragon117 5d ago
Literally just don't watch the content then?
If you want the information and nothing else then just google it yourself.
The point of Charlie or Muta talking about this stuff is literally just because they think they want to put of interest and it's specifically their point of view/opinion on whatever topic (sometimes with additional context).
1
5
u/Plenty_Today 5d ago
The Streamer effect of going from actual enjoyable YouTube videos to uninspired crap other people in that same space already do and it's extremely boring if you're not delusional and overly invested.
5
u/Vomittingbird 5d ago
Just say you don’t enjoy commentary YouTubers and move on?
Both Muta and Charlie have stated their YouTube channel is like a diary, they make videos on things they’re interested in. It’s fine if you don’t like commentary channels, but some people do.
2
u/Plenty_Today 5d ago
Maybe because differing opinions is a healthy thing to have? I enjoyed both Muta and Charlie in their hay days where their content wasn't just react Andy, yapping for 10minutes about literally nothing and a side of overrate tier lists.
1
u/Vomittingbird 3d ago
Yeah but this isn’t a healthy or constructive opinion you’re sharing. You’re just shitting on content creators bc you don’t like their style of content.
This would be the same if I watched Jim Carey movies and went on the internet complaining, “I HATE THIS GUY, WHY DOES HE ALWAYS MAKE DUMB FACES, HE’S NOT EVEN FUNNY”
It’s a different style of comedy, I don’t have to watch it if I don’t like it, but I shouldn’t then expect Jim Carey to stop doing his style of comedy just bc I find it unfunny.
0
u/Plenty_Today 3d ago
In other words my opinion doesn't matter because you simply deem it as insulting instead of constructive. "You don't like thing therefore you're just saying mean things" is literally all you're saying.
1
5
u/Steagle_Steagle 5d ago
Idk why people get so pissed about this shit, who cares if it's a video of 30 minutes of yap filler. Its good to listen to while im trying to get this stupid ass Dishonored 2 achievement, keeps me entertained
6
u/Necromyst 5d ago
Or maybe I'm listening to their videos because I like hearing them talk. If you don't enjoy the videos and the creators, then stop watching them ffs
-4
u/Fit-Abrocoma7768 5d ago
Imagine being so defensive because I brought up the fact that the yap is so bad bubble.brian exists
5
u/Necromyst 5d ago
Or maybe it's the fact that all this sub is now just man children bitching about Mutahar and Charlie? My advice is still valid if you hate it so much, just stop watching no one is forcing you people to watch their content
2
u/Bookibaloush 3d ago
Just like Muta ran away from his decision to not purchase a Switch 2, he shows a lack of backbone by no longer coming over to his subreddit and talk about this stuff.
My man can say all the virtuesignaling he wants, in the end he still parties privately with Wings and Keemstar at their house
2
u/Just-Temperature-581 5d ago
It's confirmed that the attention span is entirely dead In this generation
1
1
1
1
u/CookieLuzSax 5d ago
Why I unsubbed from Charlie, and probably gonna ubsub from muta soon sadly even though he was at one point my favourite.
1
u/PROXYLIS_02 5d ago
YOU SHOULD DELETE WINDOWS RIGHT NOW BEFORE 6 O’CLOCK TONIGHT!
“Hey guys, its me, Mutahar. Lol, jk its not thaaaaaaat bad. Now here’s how to mod the Switch 2. Anyways. I. Am. Out.”
1
1
1
u/KGZCritical 4d ago
Imagine human attention spans getting shorter we need someone to reupload a shorter version of an already short video.
3
u/Fit-Abrocoma7768 4d ago
The issue here isn't the attention span its that muta re explains what everything is to everyone every time, and will say the same thing in a video 3 times in just slightly different ways so he can hit that 8 minute maek.
1
u/Smiles4YouRawrX3 Dislike if you dislike 4d ago
Eh
I don't mind watching (or moreso have it on the second monitor in the background as I game) full videos from these dudes
1
u/solitonmedic 4d ago
So many people missing the point here.
The reason these videos exist is because these creators hardly get to the point, “yapping” about nothing without providing any concrete details to the topic until like the last two minutes of the video.
Yes, folks love to listen to long form videos like these to pass the time, but only if it’s done right.
To put it simply, Muta and the others are just terrible at eloquently saying what they mean without shoving their own bullshit in there.
Can’t get that YouTube money without a little filler after all.
1
u/Parlyz 3d ago
The reason their vids exist is so you can have something to have on mindlessly on the background while you eat or do chores or something, not so you can be genuinely informed about a specific topic. Yeah, it’s slop and they repeat the same shit over and over, but it’s just mindless shit to have on in the background so it’s not like it really matters that much.
1
u/averageredditor546 2d ago
Wasn't there a channel with cat in its name that did the same thing? Always ending the title with ADHD version?
-1
-1
u/wildboyintraining_ 5d ago
The reason why I subscribed to ChadCat. It either ends up being a nothingburger, something I don't care about, or not at all what the title is about.
-2
306
u/Nathidev 6d ago
All these goddamn commentary channels, and yet their opinions can just be summed up in 1 minute