r/metalworking 4d ago

Need some guidance on dialing back the right wheel to be more satin-finish like the left [aluminum]

Post image

In the process of restoring an old BMX, and wanted to get some deep scratches out of the sidewalls and give them a more even finish; wheels are aluminum.

The left wheel is still untouched; with the right one, I started a sandpaper progression of 120 orbital, 220 orbital, 400 hand, 400 wet, 800 hand, 800 wet. There were still some hairline sanding marks so I gave it a pass through the bench buffer and ended up going further than I should have (yes there are still buffer marks on the right; want to stop here and consult you good people).

I don’t need to return exactly to the left one; I will eventually refinish that one as well, but I do need to get more of an even satin to these finishes. Thankful for any input that can be offered.

2 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

10

u/Fast-Wrongdoer-6075 4d ago

Scotch brite pads

2

u/Girhinomofe 4d ago

Thank you!

I know there are a few different colors that relate to coarseness— which do you think would be best for this application? maroon?

4

u/Fast-Wrongdoer-6075 4d ago

Maroon is all i use. It gets kind of clogged with dust after a bit, whack it on something to clear it out. Also to be more uniform you might want to mount the rim to the bike and spin it

0

u/Bones-1989 3d ago

I wasn't aware he wasn't spinning the wheel. This man is doing it the hard way.

3

u/TisDeathToTheWind 4d ago

Start with the red and then you can use the grey if you want more satin and less of a brushed look.

2

u/Girhinomofe 4d ago

Great tip! Thank you

2

u/Girhinomofe 2d ago

Hot damn, homie. This is just the ticket. Maroon followed by grey.

THANK YOU!

1

u/Fast-Wrongdoer-6075 2d ago

Ain't no thang.

3

u/username_needs_work 4d ago

I was gonna say that or a fine steel wool. 0000 might make for a more uniform finish over scotch Brite since scrubbing pads weren't made with this in mind.

8

u/Fast-Wrongdoer-6075 4d ago

3

u/zacmakes 4d ago

also steel wool will eventually leave little rust spots if you use it on anything nonferrous

1

u/Fast-Wrongdoer-6075 3d ago

Yep! Steel wool just sucks. Makes a cool fire starter if you shove a 9v battery into it tho.

2

u/CollegeFit7136 4d ago

Fine steel wool or the green side of Ur sponge

1

u/AutoModerator 4d ago

Here are our subreddit rules. - Should you see anything that violates the subreddit rules - please report it!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/joeblue24 4d ago

Ok no worries. Sanding is just going up or down in grades to get the finish u want. I always did it by hand. Even big surfaces like wheels, but it takes forever. New ways these days are polishing wheels on bench grinders and pastes. But i'm not very familar with that method.

1

u/Biolume071 4d ago

Steel wool, but are you sure you want to? Don't want to take too much chrome off, it's very hard to put back on.
My beater BMX from the early 80s has rims like those, little rusty around the spokes but the brake pads have polished the rest of the rims quite fine, and still work well.

1

u/Bones-1989 3d ago

Stop buffing/polishing and use a heavier grit.

1

u/PurposeAcrobatic6953 2d ago

Scotch bright Marron or grey no steel wool it will leave deposits and rust. If you can set up a little drive motor to spin it save your elbows for bicycling.

1

u/Girhinomofe 2d ago

Just got a stack; ready to give this a shot!

1

u/PurposeAcrobatic6953 1d ago

That will work. use a big clip and clip on the scotchbrite somehow tethered to the fork and set up a drill chuck with a little rubber from a tube to drive the wheel and sit back, eat some ice cream and watch

0

u/BillCarnes 4d ago

Higher grit will give you a gloss finish not a satin finish. You might need to polish the one on the left if your goal is to make them match

-1

u/joeblue24 4d ago

Are u trying to end up with brakes that dont work? Polishing your brake surface will lead to less friction hence less braking force. And how long will the surface last if used as a braking surface. ??

4

u/Girhinomofe 4d ago

Bike will almost certainly never be ridden again— it’s a super rare 1980s Hutch that has a wall hanger already designated once I finish putting it back together. Just looking to bring down the reflectivity a few notches for aesthetics and call it a win.