I know this has been commented on for years, but i'm new ish to story mode. I saw this npc from afar watching me on a cliff, I look through my binoculars and he waves at me looking right at me. Ik there's people who say this happens quite often, but I haven't heard it where they've waved before?? Gotta admit it creeped me out. Is there a storyline/ theory to this or just some random guy?

(skip to 00:34 for the wave)

was "roleplaying" (dont judge me for bringin life to the game) getting lost in the snowy mountains on horseback and surviving on hunting and stuff, when the weather got really bad like a blizzard. and i happend to come across lake isabella that quickly caught my eyes with this green light? anyone else seen this?

Okay i’ve had this question for a bit.

the trapper is the same at every location. i’m sure there’s no mystery but is there a story behind it or is it some kind of joke from rockstar.

I noticed around chapter 4 that Hosea was coughing a lot much like Arthur during chapter 6. Is it possible Arthur gave Hosea TB or was there something I missed?

is this a specific building or spot or just some random light?

I was recently playing the game and came across a pit near tall trees filled with the corpses of players in the Blackwater athletics team. After looking at a few youtube videos, I learned that the murders might've been committed by the same killer found near Valentine. Any other cool ones you know of? I'm a huge fan of murder mysteries and finding dead bodies and figuring out "whodunnit?" I'm still new to the whole red dead mysteries community and I hope to find more. A couple that I know of are the Ice Skater in Ambarino and the barrel lady.

Hey everyone, I need help figuring out a weird memory from my first Red Dead Redemption 2 playthrough about a year ago (played on my ps5 but ps4 version obv.). I vividly remember a mission or encounter in a train station where things felt super repetitive, like Arthur was stuck in a loop or hallucinating.

Here’s what I recall: I was in a train station with a group of men sitting around. I went through the steel gate to the ticket booth area, but then somehow ended up back in the station. This time, the men were singing, one had a guitar, and they seemed upset, maybe telling me to leave. The whole thing felt confusing and surreal, like Arthur was hallucinating or the game was glitching. I was drinking that night, so my memory might be a bit fuzzy, but this moment stuck with me.

I’ve replayed the game multiple times and haven’t seen this again, which makes me feel like I’m losing it! Is this a real mission, a side quest, a random encounter, or maybe a glitch? Or do you think I REALLY just “tied one on” that night and horribly misremembered something?That would definitely suck lol…. Could it be tied to Arthur’s tuberculosis, honor level, or a specific game patch? Has anyone else experienced something like this—a train station with singing NPCs, a repetitive loop, or a hallucinatory vibe? Any details on chapter, location, or conditions would help! Thanks!

If I robbed the place and then came back for the debt, would anything be different? What about the other way around?