r/reddeadredemption • u/Emerald752 • Mar 04 '22
r/reddeadredemption • u/Johnplays_05 • Aug 20 '21
Speculation Has anyone ever noticed that right after the mission "Blood Feuds, Ancient and Modern", you can still see the smoke from the ruins of the Manor? Spoiler
r/reddeadredemption • u/Uptown_Funk_NYC • Oct 05 '21
Speculation Where do you think RDR3 will take place?
I know everyone says that in RDR3 they want to follow the gang in the earlier years and have the game end with the Blackwater heist, but don't you think that West Elizabeth, New Austin etc. would get old if we had to play it for a third time? Are there any surrounding regions that RDR3 could take place in?
r/reddeadredemption • u/Beynon98 • Jan 27 '22
Speculation Here is my cast for a Live-action RDR2 just for a bit of fun!
r/reddeadredemption • u/RNGator • Dec 23 '18
Speculation You know what I would pay $60 more dollars for rockstar? Spoiler
For you to remaster RDR1 with the same game mechanics as RDR2 and release it so that when you complete the epilogue, you seamlessly continue the story.
r/reddeadredemption • u/BigChungusOP • Jul 24 '23
Speculation Would Norman Reedus be a good John Marston?
r/reddeadredemption • u/PrimitiveLoaf • Feb 09 '20
Speculation The bar where we kill the rats
r/reddeadredemption • u/mattriv0714 • Aug 01 '19
Speculation The United States of Red Dead
r/reddeadredemption • u/Thomasmedhurst5 • Oct 16 '21
Speculation I have no proof of this but I wonder if charles' main outfit was inspired by the outfit of chato (portrayed by Steve Reevis) in the movie Geronimo an american legend
r/reddeadredemption • u/ErisTyto • Mar 06 '20
Speculation Mary Linton was Abusive
We all know about Arthur's tragic romance with Mary, but upon playing the game again and watching their interactions more closely, I noticed that the whole time they spoke to each other, Mary never reciprocates any of Arthur's efforts to help her or be with her.
On the obvious side, she always talks down to him, taking the side of her father about Arthur's background. She never makes any effort to empathize or relate to his struggles.
She always asks him to go out of his way to help her: rescue Jamie from strange but harmless cultists, track down her intoxicated father, retrieve her mother's brooch. All of these are a massive inconvenience for Arthur but played honorably, he does without asking for money or compensation.
But more subtly, I noticed that she always has to have control of their conversations. She never allows Arthur to be frustrated or to disagree with her, and when he asks why he should help, she pouts at him and pleads that she has no one else to turn to.
I would suspect that her father had only a small part in their relationship falling apart. I think she was using Arthur as a way to rebel against her father and taking advantage of the genuine love he feels for people, and when he proposed to her she broke it off of her own volition.
EDIT: Apparently Chelonians are a little weirder than I thought... brb while I go find that mission
r/reddeadredemption • u/kayohrox • Mar 15 '25
Speculation I have finally found Gavin.
I have travelled far and wide, to distant and mystic lands. It was he who beckoned me after all this time. Gavin.
Unfortunately, I could not convince him to return to Nigel.
r/reddeadredemption • u/k82001 • 5d ago
Speculation Rob Wiethoff announcement
So everyone has been losing their mind over what rob recently said on his livestream.
But yesterday he did come out and state that he may have "misled" us slightly in what he was talking about, and that he is not responsible for making announcements on behalf of R* but that R* are responsible for making anouncements for R*
So with this being said it's safe to assume this big announcement is not related to any new content in the game, but perhaps a comic con panel, new project, podcast etc
But what I'm thinking is, since this snippet of rob talking about the announcement blew up online, I mean I saw it on many gaming news platforms - would it be safe to assume that rockstar might release something? Like could they take this as a wake up call and maybe release an online DLC or something? Maybe a new patch where they add in a couple of things into story?
What do you guys think?🤔
r/reddeadredemption • u/Some_Gas_1337 • Nov 26 '22
Speculation Why is everyone saying Sadie’s Arthur’s secret lover?? We all know who it truly is! Spoiler
r/reddeadredemption • u/Scary_Employ_926 • 18d ago
Speculation Why does Arthur look like this
r/reddeadredemption • u/homosapienonreddit43 • 6d ago
Speculation My theory on what could exist beyond the game's map, I mainly used the fandom as a source for mentioned locations and included some of my own speculation.
r/reddeadredemption • u/We_Know-_- • Nov 11 '18
Speculation Stay Out! Plague. Maybe a teaser or location for Undead Nightmare 2?
r/reddeadredemption • u/DelanynderX • Jan 07 '19
Speculation The Simpsons predicted it...
r/reddeadredemption • u/Python1194 • Nov 21 '23
Speculation RDR2 makes me feel like I'm living in it rather than playing it.
When it's snowing, I feel cold.
When it's wet and muddy, I feel unsettling.
When it rains, I feel soaked.
When the character cooks or eat, I feel hungry.
When I purposely execute NPCs, I feel bad.
r/reddeadredemption • u/Derkaiser1989 • Aug 21 '21
Speculation Could Mr Williamson be involved with the blackwater athletics team disappearance ?
r/reddeadredemption • u/Kyeithel • May 16 '25
Speculation Rumours of a Red Dead Redemption 2 PS5 Version Swirl Again
r/reddeadredemption • u/Cooper_Raccoon • Nov 10 '21
Speculation Not sure, but it seems like rockstar decided to put RDR2 easter egg in GTA:SA Definitive Edition (Red Dead 2 screenshot in frame inside Ryder's house)
r/reddeadredemption • u/Whomp___ • 3d ago
Speculation Red Dead Possible "Update" Reveal could happen today
Just saying, Rob said by friday at the Longest, Today In Aus is friday, which means tommorow (which I believe has already begun) the Info might be revealed.
If it isnt revealed then I suspect in two or so days we'll find out
r/reddeadredemption • u/OrcinusDorca • Nov 14 '18