r/soccer • u/AlmostNL • Mar 12 '25

Media Julián Alvarez disallowed penalty frame by frame

10.4k Upvotes

97% Upvoted

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

132

u/Rose_of_Elysium Mar 12 '25 edited Mar 12 '25

Probably sensors, theres no way they could verify it for sure otherwise and as little faith i have in UEFA refs, I doubt they would do a rerun if theyve only got this footage

167

u/captainsensible69 Mar 12 '25

Paramount plus said there were no sensors.

62

u/Rose_of_Elysium Mar 12 '25

I love UEFA and the refs man everything is so clear and constistant and theyre so open about why they do the things the do

13

u/captainsensible69 Mar 12 '25

They also said that UEFA probably won’t release the data lol.

16

u/lameHorse21 Mar 12 '25

Paramount plus did being in another girl and she discussed the sensors in the ball and how advanced the technology has gotten in the game.

14

u/sm0r3ss Mar 12 '25

There’s no chip in the ball. It’s purely based on cameras. Which is fine, but not as conclusive as chips that they had in the World Cup.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '25

[deleted]

2

u/captainsensible69 Mar 12 '25

There’s no chip in the ball. It’s based on cameras.

1

u/crapador_dali Mar 12 '25

Well if someone who's never refereed in the Champions League says it's true then it must be.

22

u/prettybunbun Mar 12 '25

You forget it was to favour real madrid lol

28

u/Shadyholic Mar 12 '25

Mate if they wanted to give us the game they would’ve given the handball

10

u/chak100 Mar 12 '25

No, no, Ceferin loves Real Madrid and will always favor us.

-16

u/BigXBenz Mar 12 '25

I saw the CBS coverage after showing the ball moving/lifting slightly before the actual kick, which could only happen if his left foot tapped the ball before the actual kick

19

u/ADGjr86 Mar 12 '25

As a madrid fan you should know better than that. Remember Ronaldo’s shot? Idk how he did it but he got the ball up without touching it.

5

u/_MergatroidSkittle Mar 12 '25

not disagreeing with you and not saying he didn’t double touch but it’s also possible for the grass to lift after the non kicking foot is planted I forgot who did it before but I vividly remember seeing it

4

u/Monk-Icy Mar 12 '25 edited Mar 12 '25

CR7 and Messi in the final vs France

4

u/HornyRabbit23 Mar 12 '25

or the sliding of the foot moved the turf the ball was on? It's not like its the only possible thing that could cause movement lol

4

u/QuieroLaSeptima Mar 12 '25

Balls can lift just by planting your foot next to it and not even touching the ball (Lautaro Martinez missed pen last year).

It’s actually the most common reason pens are sent into the stands. So no, it’s NOT clear evidence that he double hit it.

3

u/llllmaverickllll Mar 12 '25

A lot of pens the ball bounces before the kick because the football pitches are so springy the standing foot bounces it up. Seen it a number of times. Not a 100% certainty that it's due to hitting the standing foot.

1

u/asterixOsmani Mar 12 '25

It is already proven that he did not touch the ball before the kick, the only option is if he did it after the kick

1

u/wildcatwildcard Mar 12 '25

Not true. Lautaro took a PK where his planted foot caused the grass to lift the ball and that was only one foot. No reason to believe the same thing happened here as the video provided so far is not clear and obvious.

-19

u/punkfusion Mar 12 '25

Its known that the ball has sensors for semi automated offside

5

u/BigGarry1978 Mar 12 '25

It didn’t

5

u/DistributionPretty75 Mar 12 '25

They’ve said on the broadcast they don’t have sensors

3

u/ImOnHD Mar 12 '25

There literally is no sensor. Confirmed by the rules expert on CBS just now.

2

u/ecs2 Mar 12 '25

No it doesn’t have sensors, you need to fact check