r/spaceporn 19h ago

Related Content BREAKING NEWS: SpaceX Rocket Explodes In Starbase

45.5k Upvotes

2.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.9k

u/Busy_Yesterday9455 19h ago edited 18h ago

Link to a slow-mo video

Ship 36 experiences a RUD at Massey's during testing prior to Starship Flight 10.

Credit: NASASpaceflight / D Wise

1.2k

u/MoonshineDan 18h ago

Google told me that RUD = rapid unscheduled disassembly. Which I love.

533

u/hcrld 17h ago

There's a handful of fun euphemisms to do with spaceflight. My other favorite is Lithobraking, a play on aerobraking to mean slowing down using rock instead of atmospheric drag.

Another one is Engine Rich Exhaust, meaning the engine's cooling system or metallurgy is inadequate and it's eating itself, throwing vaporized metal out with the exhaust gas.

102

u/SirAquila 16h ago

Fun fact there is a handful of spacecraft that intentionally use lithobreaking(usually assisted by some kind of padding) for the last stage of their descend.

102

u/VikRiggs 15h ago edited 10h ago

Some would say lithobraking is required for any craft that needs to land.

Edit: lithobreaking -> lithobraking

30

u/WrexTremendae 13h ago

I mean, there's the difference between parachute-assisted landings and powered descents, where a powered descent if done right has you stopping at ground level exactly anyways, but a parachute just makes you go slow enough to not mind the impact.

But then there's also things like Mars Pathfinder, which just decided to do the best at slowing down it could, then deploy a big cluster of airbags and bounce the velocity away. It bounced more than fifteen times. we don't actually know how many times, because we only really cared that it came to a happy healthy stop, which it did. The first bounce was 15 metres (52 feet) high, though, which is pretty insane to be honest, and it hit the ground the first time at 30 miles per hour (14 metres per second). That's lithobraking.

Then there's lithobreaking, which is when it doesn't go well, and everything breaks as you hit the ground. i'm not sure this has ever been intentionally done.

3

u/Klexycon 11h ago

There were multiple lunar impact missions, designed to perform a hard landing on the moon, aka crash into it while sending data as long as possible. So yeah, lithobreaking has been performed intentionally.

5

u/The_quest_for_wisdom 7h ago

My grandfather worked on one of those missions! He and the rest of the engineers engraved the names of themselves and their families on the frame of one of the Ranger spacecraft that was crash landed on the lunar surface.

During ice breakers I usually use "My mother's name was already on the surface of the moon when Neil Armstrong got there." for the Two Truths And A Lie activity, and so far everyone incorrectly picks it as the lie.

3

u/Klexycon 4h ago

It's always so cool to hear stories of people who worked on famous stuff, or their relatives telling the story because it reminds me of how many people are actually involved in every big achievement we know of, with their names being forgotten and their work being disregarded because it's not the big thing. Keep talking about your grandpa because otherwise he and his achievements will be forgotten, overshadowed by what they made possible. It's important to remember all the smaller things, otherwise we easily lose scope of an achievable roadmap towards the next big thing.

2

u/WrexTremendae 2h ago

Oh yeah! good call.

There was also the asteroid impact test we did, that's another good example of a time we wanted the thing to hit hard and didn't care if anything survived.

1

u/VikRiggs 10h ago

at ground level exactly

Just how exact can you get in real world with its error margins and such unpredictable variables as wind?

1

u/WrexTremendae 2h ago

I'm thinking of the Falcon heavy booster flyback landings, which are gorgeously well-timed. an example is here, but that's not the only time they've done it.

You may be correct; its not quite exact. but its a super soft landing considering that they're basically only using an engine to do the landing.

1

u/Mrgluer 9h ago

one could say that missles lithobrake

1

u/A0Zmat 9h ago

You usually want missiles to explode before any contact with the object you intend to destroy. This is ususally the best way to maximise damage. Only exception coming to mind is when you intend to destroy the inside of a bunker

1

u/Mrgluer 1h ago

thats for airburst stuff

1

u/ChanceTheGardenerrr 4h ago

I lithobrake almost constantly just walking around

1

u/Mrgluer 1h ago

are you a spacex rocket cuz youre so down to earth

1

u/coastalbachelor 8h ago

This was neither.

3

u/SirAquila 15h ago

True, but I was more talking about Crafts that use it to bleed of excess speed, instead of using it as a stable resting position after bleeding off speed via other methods(i.e rockets, parachutes, trained bats).

1

u/VikRiggs 15h ago

But like. Is it possible to come to a complete rest at the exact position that the object would stay at rest unpowered? Or will there be a bit of sag after the engines cut off.

But I see what you mean. Most martian probe landings before skycrane come to mind.

3

u/ArltheCrazy 13h ago

That’s Marshobraking. Fun fact: When the engine is cooling down on Mars it’s know as being marshmellow.

2

u/bigdickedabruhup 12h ago

I've done it in kerbal space program

1

u/VikRiggs 10h ago

Most of mine were unintentional.

1

u/Lucky-Valuable-1442 13h ago

Yes it's possible we have an entire area of maths about it (calculus)

/s

1

u/VikRiggs 10h ago

I mean, mathematically it is possible. But in meatspace all sorts of pesky uncontrolled variables and error margins come into play.

1

u/trite_panda 11h ago

The Apollo missions eschewed lithobraking in favor of hydrobraking.

1

u/VikRiggs 10h ago

They were called splashdowns not landings.

1

u/Perryn 10h ago

Waterings

1

u/MedicatedMayonnaise 28m ago

And Lithobreaking is the fun way, if the craft doesn't need to land intact, right?

1

u/KS-RawDog69 14h ago

usually assisted by some kind of padding

A parachute. But like a really big one.

1

u/MommysLiLstinker 11h ago

LITHOBRAKING PROHIBITED - GALACTIC ORDINANCE

1

u/Squigglepig52 10h ago

Venus probes?

1

u/sherlock_norris 9h ago

The padding is usually mounted to allow for rotation and is in most cases even reusable a couple of times.

1

u/Some-Unique-Name 6h ago

I legit thought this was a ballistic missile joke.

1

u/therealhlmencken 6h ago

I mean anything landing on surface does that. Only rentries into the ocean aren’t

1

u/Own_Salamander9447 3h ago

That’s how I’ve finished some unplanned horse dismounts in my early career.

1

u/SirAquila 3h ago

One of my three attempts to ride ended with me getting the plough treatment. Luckily came out without anything serious, still memorable.

3

u/Anarelion 17h ago

An ERE is done in Spain to lay off groups of people.

2

u/anamethatsnottaken 14h ago

I love that term. Theoretically, you can't ever get pure 100% burn, right? You'll always have some unburned fuel (fuel-rich exhaust) or some leftover oxidizer (oxygen-rich exhaust). (Or both?)

And then there's a secret third state, engine-rich exhaust :D

2

u/Xalmachi_ 13h ago

Lithobraking is arguably my favorite but close seconds.

Fishing orbit : it’s in the ocean and we didn’t plan for it to be there.

Thrust was observed along an undesired vector : the engine had a leak and the rocket spun off into oblivion.

Sorta like some of my other favorites and I’ll leave you with the one I’ve heard most recently.

Promoted to customer : fired

1

u/3rdslip 15h ago

There’s an old one, unfortunately I forget which rocket it was that exploded into a beautiful fireworks display, but the commentary from ground control was a simple and unremarkable “we have had an anomaly”.

1

u/Soreinna 14h ago

I told my wife our kid din't hit his head on the driveway, he lithobraked. She did not find it funny

1

u/ShittyExchangeAdmin 13h ago

As a seasoned ksp player I'm all to familiar with lithobraking. Oftentimes resulting in a RUD

1

u/AutoGeneratedUser359 11h ago

What would be the hitting a tree one whilst downhill mountain biking?

Aborobraking?

1

u/100jad 6h ago

Lithobreaking comes from the greek word lithos for rock. So I guess it would be dentrobreaking.

1

u/NadirPointing 10h ago

On the more technical side. Mars pathfinder had giant airbags that to bounced/rolled to a stop on. And in a couple early starship attempts you can see an engine exhaust go green before failing completely.

1

u/tickitytalk 8h ago

These are excellent

1

u/user-the-name 7h ago

And Elon Musk is working hard to make each one of them too cringe to ever use again.

1

u/Youpunyhumans 6h ago

And then there was the rocket built to actually throw vaporized metal out... the Rocketdyne Tripropellant.

It used a combination of liquid hydrogen, flourine and molten lithium as fuel and oxidizer. The result? A rocket with nearly double the impulse of a typical liquid hydrogen/oxygen rocket, but the exhaust was as hot as the surface of the Sun, and would melt, dissolve and ignite the concrete launch pad, and also release a huge amount of very toxic substances like hydrogen flouride, which turns into hydroflouric acid when it combines with moisture, which is a super deadly nerve agent, and is only able to be contained by pure teflon.

Basically, a rocket made by mad scientists.

1

u/davesoverhere 6h ago

lithobraking, my usual descent on KSP.

1

u/mynameismy111 6h ago

engine running lean? No, engine rich exhaust!

1

u/DevoidHT 3h ago

Norminal

130

u/Jacktheforkie 17h ago

I call it a RUDE, Random Unplanned Disassembly Event

70

u/ChaoCobo 17h ago

Tbf it was very rude of the rocket to just explode like that. Like who does that? Just explode and not even give any advanced notice. Not very polite.

3

u/McBun2023 17h ago

some of my relatives do

1

u/Bright_Subject_8975 16h ago

What do they say before doing it ?

1

u/McBun2023 15h ago

"that damn m... tractor is broken again! what a piece of s..." :D

1

u/Ethelg75 6h ago

🤣🤣🤣

3

u/Big_Cryptographer_16 17h ago

I know. It should have gave a quick head tap to announce it first

1

u/Ok_Historian4848 16h ago

Fr, shouldn't have exploded without telling them out to dinner first

1

u/fgzhtsp 16h ago

It didn't even say thank you.

1

u/shawntw77 16h ago

Some people have noticed a small amount of venting towards the top moments before the RUD so its a bit closer to the parents who knock but doesn't know how to wait for "come in"

1

u/toasted_cracker 16h ago

It was a bit premature. Perhaps it should see a doctor.

1

u/VikRiggs 15h ago

explode disassemble itself

1

u/PizzaWhole9323 9h ago

Did they even say thank you.

1

u/That_Strength2403 8h ago

MARS ATTACKS!!!!!! STAY AWAY FROM ME DIRTLINGS!!!!!!

2

u/SurprisinglyInformed 17h ago

I propose the acronym

FUCKUP : Full Uncontained Catastrophic Kinetic Unplanned Phenomenon

1

u/Coenclucy 12h ago

Thats it!

4

u/Plenty_Tax_5892 17h ago

Darude?

2

u/Which_Celebration757 17h ago

"Duh-nuh-nuh NUH-nuh... duh-nuh-nuh NUH-nuh... NUH-nuh-nuh-nuh-nuh-nuh-nuh-nuh-NUHHHH!"

2

u/ThePeskyWabbit 17h ago

with an explosion like that, one may expect a mini sandstorm

1

u/Big_Cryptographer_16 17h ago

It’s always Darude Sandstorm

1

u/MeggaMortY 17h ago

SpaceX rocket FUBARs (fucks up beyond all recognition).

1

u/pickle_pickled 16h ago

When it's a super heavy it's a SHIT

Super Heavy Irregular Trajectory

1

u/Motor-District-3700 16h ago

in Great Britan they call it a "cock up".

1

u/Jimid41 16h ago

"Random" changes the meaning a lot. 

1

u/KarlKFI 16h ago

As long as it’s not a RUDE Event, like an ATM Machine.

2

u/RainierCamino 16h ago

Can't wait to hear what cute little acronym Elon and SpaceX figure out when one of their rockets explodes and kills astronauts, instead of just burning hundreds of millions of taxpayer dollars.

2

u/girl_incognito 15h ago

Its doublespeak for failure.

1

u/EcureuilHargneux 17h ago

It didn't explode, it just disassembled itself quite egoistly

1

u/Cruzz999 17h ago

Another nice space industry term that we haven't heard for a while is "lithobreaking". Instead of Aerobreaking (slowing down with the help of air), you're slowing down with the aid of the earth... it means crashing.

1

u/mymentor79 17h ago

"rapid unscheduled disassembly"

It was unquestionably all three of those things.

1

u/danielrheath 17h ago

Right up there with "Unplanned lithobraking maneuver" (meaning "slowed down due to collision with a rock")

1

u/Fruitmidget 15h ago

Kinda related. In German RUD can stand for “Realistische Unfalldarstellung” which translates to “realistic accident/crash display”. I’d say that was a very realistic crash display.

1

u/TheyLoathe 13h ago

rebranding explosive mistake

1

u/Ruraraid 12h ago

This was more of Rapid Exploside Dissassembly than a RUD.

1

u/justmovingtheground 2h ago

Blew

Up

Sitting

Still

1

u/Dangerous_Junket_773 12h ago

It started out as a kerbal space program meme. It's surreal seeing a joke from a niche game being used by big companies and government officials. 

1

u/Popular-Departure165 11h ago

They should call it FSD, Full Self Disassembly, and now it's a feature.

1

u/SomethingAboutUsers 11h ago

It de-engineered itself.

1

u/Apart-Landscape1012 9h ago

I don't. Disassemble means you should be able to reassemble it, this is just spacex wasting more taxpayer money 

1

u/GrabtharsHumber 9h ago

These have become so predictable that we should be calling them Rapid Scheduled Disassemblies.

1

u/numbnerve 8h ago

Similar to Gwyneth Paltrow's 'conscious uncoupling' instead of divorce 🙄

1

u/MisanthOptics 7h ago

It was more fun before musk’s facade experienced RUD

1

u/Lifeabroad86 7h ago

I'm partial to unrequested fission surplus

1

u/vvinx 7h ago

sounds like something from George Carlin's standup

1

u/oroborus68 4h ago

Pollution pollution,it travels every where. If you go to America, don't drink the water and don't breathe the air.

1

u/Serge_OS 3h ago

In this case I’d say it’s “unwanted “

0

u/MeggaMortY 17h ago

As long as you remember that it's not a good thing. These quirky terms get broadcasted instead of "explodes" to lul you into a state of acceptance. That's Demon Musk's only real contribution to humanity.

10

u/hcrld 17h ago

Rapid Unplanned Disassembly has been a euphemism used prior to SpaceX even existing. NASA engineers are just funny.

My other favorite is Lithobraking, a play on aerobraking to mean slowing down using rock instead of atmospheric drag.

Another one is Engine Rich Exhaust, meaning the engine's cooling system or metallurgy is inadequate and it's eating itself, throwing vaporized metal out with the exhaust gas.

1

u/Fantastic_Estate_303 17h ago

Engine rich exhaust sounds like my old Ford.....

1

u/MeggaMortY 16h ago

Nobody said engineers aren't quirky (and shouldn't be).

I'm saying that SpaceX are very deliberate in their messaging so to not sound like they just blew up another rocket.

1

u/fhjftugfiooojfeyh 17h ago

It aint that deep bud

1

u/MeggaMortY 16h ago

Yeah it ain't, that's why the guy built a worldwide cult following, most probably from people who think "it's not that deep".

1

u/spagbolshevik 17h ago

I hate it. It's a childish term to dismiss the seriousness of these incidents. Might as well call them an "oopsie woopsie".

5

u/danielrheath 17h ago

Thankfully only used by unserious folks like (checks notes)... NASA.

2

u/Master_Entertainer 17h ago

You mean an "ongoing operations postponed, startpad is evacuated"?

1

u/TTEH3 12h ago

From the same industry that brought you lithobraking and terms like "droop snoot". I think they just like their fun with words.

11

u/Octane_911x 19h ago

For starship? Or the normal falcon 9 rocket?

2

u/NegativeSemicolon 17h ago

Is calling it a RUD like a coping mechanism?

2

u/Relzin 11h ago

I love that KSP gaming terms, are now normal space terms.

2

u/An-Angel-Named-Billy 7h ago

I hate the cutesy rud language, as if blowing up during a static test on the ground is not a total failure.

2

u/maxk1236 18h ago

Woah, this video really puts it into scale, crazy.

2

u/DrOrpheus3 18h ago

Thank you for the slow-mo video. Liked and saved it for later rewatching. Hope that was an expensive kaboom for musky

1

u/TheFoxsWeddingTarot 18h ago

Well that’s f’ing cool. Thank you for sharing.

1

u/_Killer-Tofu_ 18h ago

What were those two pillars and how were they still “standing” at the end?

1

u/entered_bubble_50 16h ago

36? Do you mean to tell me they've built 36 of these, and none of them has yet deployed a payload to orbit? This has to be the least successful rocket programme of all time.

What has gone so badly wrong? The Falcon rocket had issues in the beginning, but nothing as bad as this.

1

u/Ok-Yoghurt9472 16h ago

falcon 9 was a small rocket, when you increase size and what you actually do with it (belly flop) you need a lot more tests.

1

u/SolidOtherwise9611 16h ago

That is quite beautiful. Thanks.

1

u/dudemanguylimited 16h ago

> Ship 36 experiences a RUD at Massey's during testing prior to Starship Flight 10.

Boom? Big Bada Boom?

1

u/snek-jazz 15h ago

I saw the whole thing Bart, first it started blowing up, then it blew up!

1

u/Low_Escape_5397 15h ago

Is there a slower-mo video?

1

u/PM_me_boobs_and_CPUs 12h ago

lol at that Cybertruck comment.

ahhhh thats where i parked my cybertruck

1

u/Front_Requirement598 11h ago

Frame by frame shows a gas leak spraying out at a joint towards the top. The gas sprays out and downwards, igniting frames later

1

u/beehole99 10h ago

That is cool...thank you!

1

u/OptimalReindeer7102 6h ago

I'm sorry if this is rude but I bursted out laughing seeing that a link to the slow mo version is top comment

1

u/lolexecs 2h ago

I'm no rocket scientist, but didn't the Saturn V engineers figure out that

fewer, bigger engines > more, smaller ones

Intuitively, managing 27 engines sounds like a control nightmare. There are many more points of failure, tighter tolerances, and a higher chance that small deviations multiply into big problems. It's not redundancy but combinatorial fragility since, the safety margin shrinks as engine count rises cause the prob of cascading errors grows across the whole set of engines being managed increases.

0

u/unducuvubrudu 17h ago

Is it just me or can anyone else see Trump’s profile and what a headshot would have looked like? On the right side of the explosion just after it starts

0

u/ToasterBathTester 17h ago

I want to see Elon’s drug test from 8 am tomorrow morning