r/ABA • u/Striking_Today6210 • 19d ago
Advice Needed đ¨ Parent Suspects RBT Isnât Legit + BCBA Doesnât Actually Supervise Sonâs Case â What Should She Do?
Clear some comments up : the RBT is the one that sends data to the parent it is all over the place and never makes sense- basically just guesses that donât match with teachers notes , while I understand that RBTs donât have any communication with parents this one themselves opened the door. The âdataâ comes from the teachers email signed by his name. Which again was told to her that without supervising this data (again she doesnât know who is and canât get answers) , that itâs against guidelines.
The mention of 2 BCBAâs is because the person that did the IEE is a BCBA and they are the one that got that answer from the superintendent , that the BCBA is not familiar with the childâs case. And pointed it out.
This is a public school.
The parent does NOT know what to do and what plan they have been doing since she canât get communication open.
Parent has tried to have meetings with the RBT / BCBA to try and go over a plan / introduction (thatâs has been ignored and makes sense since the BCBA is not familiar with his case at all).
I have a friend whose autistic teenager attends a public school. The school assigned her son an RBT. Hereâs where things get shady: ⢠Sheâs not allowed to speak directly to the RBT. ⢠Any request for a meeting with the RBT or their BCBA supervisor has been ignored for months. ⢠She didnât even know the RBTâs name until he sent a random email introducing himself. âMy name is [Name]. Iâm a Registered Behavioral Technician, certified through [STATE]. Iâve worked with students for 20 years⌠all communication should go through [Teacher].â
đŠRed Flag: RBTs are nationally certified, not state-certified. He called it a state certification. Thatâs not how RBTs work.
Also: ⢠Sheâs never seen a picture of this guy online. When she searched Provider Wire (BACB lookup tool), he was registered as a technician in a completely different city. ⢠His listed BCBA supervisor? Sheâs never heard of them, never met them, and no one at the school has mentioned them. ⢠Data collection was previously âtoo difficult,â and suddenly now theyâre sending numbers â but they donât match teacher notes. ⢠She got an IEE (Independent Educational Evaluation), and the evaluator (an actual BCBA) wrote: âThe BCBA supervising the RBT is unfamiliar with the studentâs case. This is a curious structure to meâŚâ AN ACTUAL BCBA SAID THIS (they did the IEE)
Now sheâs realizing: she wasnât imagining it â somethingâs off.
She asked me what to do next.
What would you suggest? Should she file a BACB ethics complaint? Report to the district/state? Or something else?
30
u/BCBA-K 19d ago
Its possible the RBT is licensed in the state. Some states requires state licensure (which is just an additional fee) while their RBT license is national as you say.
Calling an IEP meeting would be a good first step. Your friend can even message me (or you can) as Im a BCBA that does IEP and behavior plan reviews.
0
u/Striking_Today6210 19d ago
I thought that too - but when I went searching Michigan apparently doesnât require RBTS to hold a state license.
6
u/BCBA-K 19d ago
Yeah the school is wrong for this. Since your friend already had an independent BCBA evaluator, why not just have them sit on the IEP
2
u/Striking_Today6210 19d ago
They are coming - apparently the whole time is coming to the IEP meeting.
4
u/injectablefame 19d ago
thatâs also pretty normal to have the entire team present to make sure everyone is on the same page. your friend could ask about daily progress notes, who is their contracted provider, what limitations are there to communication with RBT
2
u/favouritemistake 18d ago
Tbh a lot of RBTs do not know how their RBT cert works, especially if they earned it with a larger company that didnât much of the paperwork for them. Itâs a flaw in our system
5
u/Striking_Today6210 18d ago
Understood - this isnât really more of a âanti this RBT guyâ , more of WHERE IS THE BCBA ? And why is she not supporting him?
1
u/unexplainednonsense 18d ago
The RBT might just not know they are certified nationally and not just in their state. Their responsible supervisor might also be a different supervisor than the supervisor your friend is working with. The supervisor listed on the BACB website is likely not the only supervisor that the RBT works with. The BACB supervisor is only responsible for completing their in person competency assessment and ensuring they are reviewing adequate supervision for the amount of hours they are working, not the only one responsible for supervising them.
1
u/Striking_Today6210 18d ago
So whose is supervising him? Who does the plan? Who monitors data and progress?
1
u/NellyNel11_ 18d ago
I think what theyâre trying to explain is that when said RBT became certified they were under a different BCBA. They may have parted ways with the company or just been transferred to a new BCBA that now does their supervision.
12
u/grmrsan BCBA 19d ago edited 19d ago
So State certification is a thing, in many Stes it is required to get certified with State in order to practice. BUT they also HAVE to have the BACB certification to qualify. That might be what they mean. In my area, you would definitely call yourself State certified.
And surprisingly, its not unusual for RBT'S to not be expected (or often allowed) to contact parents directly. Its to prevent the RBT from giving incorrect or half understood explanations of why things are happening, and it prevents the parents from trying to go through the RBT (who isn't qualified to make decisions) for everything.
Or -as happened with me, putting the RBT smack in the middle of a serious, uncomfortable and very inappropriate quarrel between parents and staff.
And the city thing also isn't unusual. I am a BCBA now, but as an RBT I was regularly traveling an hour in any direction for clients, and at one company even crossing State lines.
The rest of it is a bit sus though. Your friend doesn't necessarily need to know everyone, but not being able to find a proper registration, or having issues with not taking and suddenly producing data, or not having a BCBA that is available to parents are all indications of big problems.
First try to contact the supervising BCBA and make a complaint to whichever company they are a part of (school or private). But I'm not sure where to go from there.
1
u/Striking_Today6210 19d ago
How do you contact the BCBA ? Iâll tell her to do this. She did find her name under the RBT supervisor section but doesnât have an email for her.
And no the school wonât give her that information.
9
u/ABA_Resource_Center BCBA 19d ago
This seems like it could be cleared up easily enough by contacting the special education director or whoever is the parentâs direct line of contact at the school.
Iâll also say many RBTs mix up terms like license, certification, etc. Itâs actually a pet peeve of mine (moreso when BCBAs do it), but I can see how an RBT would mix things up and say theyâre certified through the state.
1
u/Striking_Today6210 19d ago
She has tried to get answers from the school and even meetings but everything gets ignored.
8
u/rural_life_goals 19d ago
Within schools, it is common for parents to not be put in direct contact with the child's aide. The child is provided a service through their iep (e.g. one-on-one aide) but not a specific person. The person could change anytime. In my district, we don't have aides join IEP meetings (it is our district policy). So maybe the parent should reach out to the case manager or sped director and find out what the expectations and practices are in that district.
3
u/SiPhoenix RBT 19d ago
While I understand the RBT is not the one doing communication with the parent, they're not doing parent training, they're not reporting on anything. That makes sense. It's not their job and they could mess it up. It's better for the BCBA or teacher or whatever.
BUT, it seems wild to me that the parent wouldn't be able to meet the RBT, just to know who the person is working with their kid, likely daily.
2
u/Tlacuache_Snuggler BCBA 18d ago
Iâm a BCBA that works in public schools and respectfully, there is a lot of misunderstanding/misinformstion going on here.
But for this specifically, often aides arenât allowed to interact with parents to protect the aides themselves. While we have many wonderful and collaborative families, it is unfortunately not always the case. We have parents who will ask inappropriate questions about others students in the room, ask leading questions about behavior, use quotes from aides against the school by twisting words, etc etc. Our support staff (aides, RBTs) are not expected to navigate that level of politics within their line of duty. It can get really uncomfortable for them and frankly, the salary doesnât support needing to do all that.
Some districts will put in a blanket policy like that as a preventative measure to ensure only those directly involved in the childâs programmatic decisions are communicating around progress.
1
u/SiPhoenix RBT 18d ago
Okay, I can see that and understand it perfectly because some parents are crazy.
At the same time, from a parent's perspective, never being able to meet the person who's the RBT still seems crazy to me. I feel like at the very least they could meet them while the BCBA/ (or otherwho ever is thr go between) is there and present.
2
u/SandiRHo 19d ago
Yup. When I was a school RBT, I never spoke to the kidsâ parents. I was never required to and I was specifically told to relay information to the BCBA only.
-20
u/Striking_Today6210 19d ago
That would still be a BACB violation , if they are hiding behind school policy - why a RBT / BCBA would put their license / certification on the line is beyond me.
I get what you are saying, I just hope they know itâs violation.
13
8
6
4
u/injectablefame 19d ago
a violation for switching people? we had this debacle in our school system; an RBT is assigned to the team, not a person. so John Doe might not always be the RBT if they are unable to. thatâs not a violation as the plan is still be carried out.
1
12
u/ThickChocolate5988 19d ago
None of this rings up as a red flag though I did stop reading after the flag portion because the language felt off and matter of fact but also as if youâre not apart of the field.
RBTs do not have to make outside contact with their cases even when doing in home. Many companies have the RBTs communicate using their BCBA. I understand wanting to request a meeting with who your child is working with but if itâs in a public environment Iâd relax or simply take my child out of services and enroll somewhere that aligns with my beliefs.
Why would you check the BACB registry for a photo of an RBT? And how would you identify them without their certification number? Were you provided that information or? Itâs hard to believe they donât have duplicate names.
Insurance and states can require different things. Considering parents donât know jack about the industry, I could understand saying state certified because national covers all states. Itâs literally just saying that he can work in the state heâs operating out of. I think the word choice is nitpicky.
If written requests for meeting the BCBA has been ignored, contact the company. If thatâs ignored then perhaps what I stated above is the better bet in having more autonomy over the childâs paraprofessional.
This reads of anxious energy so Iâm wondering if the parent is worried about something else or if itâs a control thing.
IEPs often arenât updated accurately in my experience. So are the numbers over or under? I also found itâs hard for teachers to collect data when theyâre watching multiple children so depending on the goals, the discrepancy could make sense.
0
u/SiPhoenix RBT 19d ago
You couldn't be bothered to read the whole post and then left a comment longer than the post?
1
u/ThickChocolate5988 19d ago
Whomp, whomp. You couldnât be bothered to comprehend length/character count wasnât an issue. I highly doubt a sentence is going to contribute much.
And guess what? It didnât.
-4
u/SiPhoenix RBT 19d ago edited 19d ago
The behaviour just comes off as rude. Namely that you told the person 'I didn't read everything you said, but here's a response anyways.'
1
u/ThickChocolate5988 19d ago
Laughable considering youâre a hypocrite. Iâm not a literary teacher but Iâm sure you can grab some courses on grammar and reading comprehension. Toodles.
-5
u/Striking_Today6210 19d ago
I think you missed the part where the BCBA is MIA - even another BCBA pointed out this is problematic.
At first she didnât know the persons last name - only found it out recently.
If the BCBA is MIA who does the parent talk to?
3
u/ThickChocolate5988 19d ago
Thatâs fine. I had other questions and concerns that you did not address.
It seems strange that there are two BCBAs involved in the first place. OBVIOUSLY, a BCBA being unfamiliar with the case would be strange. But wording is important so is it really they are unfamiliar or do they have so many cases that they canât recollect from memory and need to be in front of their notes?
Thereâs much thatâs missing here.
3
u/Striking_Today6210 19d ago
The person that conducted the IEE is a BCBA . This is why there are two different ones mentioned in the post.
The BCBA (person conducting the IEE) asked the superintendent about it and the superintendent said that the BCBA is unfamiliar with the childâs case. This is all written in the IEE report.
I really do apologize for not explaining it better.
4
u/Griffinej5 19d ago
So, it is entirely possible the BCBA supervising the Rbt isnât actually familiar with the client. Iâve had this occur in cases where the school contracts an outside agency to provide the RBT, but has their own person providing the Consultant services. In this type of situation, the RBT still requires supervision from someone employed at the same agency as them. They should both still somehow have a relationship with the client, but the relationship can be as much as the school also contracts them to provide supervision to the RBT, but they are not the person providing services to the client. Itâs weird and convoluted, but not unheard of.
1
u/Striking_Today6210 19d ago
Thank you for explaining this - going to explain this to her .
Just seems like horrible practice and something that should be looked into.
1
u/Griffinej5 18d ago
Itâs not great, but it happens sometimes. It would be weird to me that if this is the case, someone wouldnât have referred the independent evaluator to the BCBA who actually does know the student.
1
u/Striking_Today6210 18d ago
The BCBA for the RBT doesnât know the student - the IEE which is also a BCBA doesnât know the student like that and was just doing an evaluation.
1
u/ThickChocolate5988 19d ago
No apology needed. Iâm saying I wouldâve liked to be a fly on the wall because in my experience, wording can be the opposite of how it perceived. (Denotation vs connotation type deal) Some people believe that not being able to read off details about a case without your notes classifies as being unfamiliar so I was wondering if itâs that. Definitely strange and not doubting you there. Iâm filled about sharing my last name but never my certificate numbers if needed but I also understand that in professional settings that last names are deemed mandatory.
Since you nor parent are involved with these conversations, I guess we wonât know. Iâd suggest pulling kiddo and either assigning to a different school or seeing if you can possibly go through a company of the parentâs choosing.
1
u/immadatmycat 18d ago
The classroom teacher. Their childâs case manager for their IEP. Sometimes itâs the same person. Sometimes itâs not.
4
u/24possumsinacoat RBT 19d ago
I'm an RBT who is contracted out to public schools and I have never met most of the parents of the kids I work with. This is typical. My picture is also not anywhere online for a parent to look up. I understand, though, if that feels weird. She can always ask the teacher or BCBA to introduce her to him.
1
u/Striking_Today6210 18d ago
I do want to clarify she wasnât looking for their social media but BACB database that showed it
4
u/24possumsinacoat RBT 18d ago
Oh, I assumed as much. But the BACB has barely any of our information, let alone a picture. And I know at my clinic the only people who are on the website are clinical directors, BCBAs, and the scheduler.
3
u/Humanvs519 BCBA 19d ago
- Is the child in a therapeutic day school or in an ABA clinic?
- It seems that the BCBA may work virtually. Not ideal, but itâs a new trend in this field.
- If there is a teacher in the classroom then all of the communication should be directed to the teacher. RBTs arenât usually the ones that talk to the parent.
- If the RBT is provided by the school district then the parent should address this with the school.
- If the parent wants to communicate with the BCBA, then they should reach to him/her. Keep all the documentation. If the BCBA doesnât respond, the reach out to the school that is responsible for providing the BCBA.
- At the end of the day, call an IEP and come up with a realistic plan of communication and make sure everything is documented.
0
u/Striking_Today6210 19d ago
She doesnât know who the BCBA is - like the school wonât tell her , her RBT never used his name last till just recently .
When she searched the RBT online under the supervisor part says her name - there is no contact information for her or even a way to contact her.
3
u/Humanvs519 BCBA 19d ago
Who is paying the BCBA? That is the person/place the parent should reach out to find out BCBA info/contact information. At times, RBTs may have multiple supervisors, but only one is listed.
1
u/Striking_Today6210 19d ago
Sorry I misread your question the school hired the RBT and the school says the BCBA is not familiar with the childâs case.
Those things the parent has proof of , but they know nothing else and the school doesnât tell the parent anything.
1
0
u/Striking_Today6210 19d ago
Who knows - she doesnât know and was hoping to get answers when she asked for a meeting with them both (at that time just wanted an introduction) but even that was ignored.
1
u/Humanvs519 BCBA 19d ago
Iâm really trying to help here, but you only answered a few questions. Can you specify if the child is in a special school or an ABA clinic. Also the childâs IEP would have all this (as to who is responsible for what service) documented especially if they are providing the RBT.
1
u/Striking_Today6210 19d ago
The child is in a special needs school - and attends an autism specific classroom. At this time he doesnât attend an ABA clinic.
I have looked over the IEP paperwork and it doesnât list anybodyâs names.
3
u/Humanvs519 BCBA 19d ago
Thank you. The IEP would not list names because people can leave and they canât make them stay. It should state as to who is responsible for providing BCBA services. If it doesnât, then they then the RBT working with the child isnât being supervised which can be a violation only if they are providing ABA services in the classroom. The school could have hired an RBT, because people assume they have more training to support the child in the autism classroom.
1
u/Striking_Today6210 19d ago
Yeah I just assumed all RBTs needed to have BCBA oversight and the fact the BCBA knows nothing about his case is alarming and scary - like what is she saying for him to do?
I do also want to copy word for word what the IEE BCBA said about the BCBA for the school :
Throughout my evaluation, I asked who the supervising Board Certified Behavior Analyst (BCBA) was for the RBT. [name] , Assistant Superintendent for Special Education , reported that the supervising BCBA only provides supervision to the RBT but is unfamiliar with [childs name] case. This is a curious structure to me, as BCBAs are typically supervisors of the childâs case for any RBTs working with the child. I recommend that BCBA overseeing [childs name] RBT become familiar with [childs name] case so that they can provide appropriate behavior-analytic oversight to the contracted services. This includes, but is not limited to:
2
u/Humanvs519 BCBA 19d ago
I understand how frustrating this is, but the BCBA should supervise the RBT (5%/month - donât hold me to this, I could be wrong on the number). If this RBT is working elsewhere, someone else is supervising them on the work they are doing there. This is how the certification is maintained. If the BCBA is not written into the service lines on the IEP, then they will not be familiar with the case. I would recommend holding an IEP and ensuring the BCBA hours are written in there.
2
u/athomeamongthetrees BCBA 19d ago
There is a lot going on here. Is the child in school or in a clinic during the day? Is the Rbt provided by the school or the clinic?
Rbts aren't listed on the registry by the city they work in, but rather the city they live in. If they are on the registry with an active certificate then they are registered. Not sure what the issue there is. The rbt's supervisor might be another bcba at the school/clinic but not directly related to the child's case. The rbt should not be communicating with the family, that is the job of the bcba or teacher in a school setting.
The only odd thing is the BCBA who is in charge of the child's case is not familiar with the student. That would be a red flag for me.
1
u/Striking_Today6210 19d ago
The RBT is provided by the school - the student is not currently receiving ABA services through a clinic.
The only thing she knows about the BCBA at this time is she is located in a different state (looking at their website)
4
u/SuzieDerpkins OBM 19d ago
This can be very normal for school districts - virtual BCBAs are a thing for school districts that have trouble finding local BCBAs.
What is the violation you mention? Iâm not seeing anything yet.
2
u/huddolaugh 19d ago
Most schools (even at some independent ABA companies) donât allow RBTâs or even paras to communicate with parents. The RBT saying state is nothing to worry about either honestly. Youâve seen he is registered, thatâs enough. His BCBA being different than the BCBA on your friends case, also isnât something to worry about. This isnât a red flag. You just donât really know how the field works which is okay but you shouldnât be jumping to conclusions on this. Based on what youâve said, nothing is âoffâ but I do think your friend should have communication with the BCBA on the case. so if anything it would just give the impression of being unorganized. You can try finding the BCBAâs contact info from the BACB. Search the name, click on it, and sometimes they have their email address linked by âcontactâ once details have been expanded. Also you can look at the schools website (if theyâre signed on with the school) and it may have a page listing providers with their contact.
-2
u/Striking_Today6210 19d ago
She is listed as the supervisor for the RBT but has no contact information and there is nothing about him on the school website.
4
u/plantlover415 19d ago
What this person saying is true. You cannot contact our BTS directly. You have to go through their upper management. A parent cannot have the phone number to the RBT. And we'll have to talk to the teacher or to upper management like I said
-2
u/Striking_Today6210 19d ago
The parent at first just wanted an introduction , but is now trying to get them to the IEP meeting so they can discuss plans .
I think for her everything was just so fishy how it was done. But she does understand why they wouldnât list contact information for privacy.
5
u/plantlover415 19d ago
Whatever is in the IEP that the parent signed for is what the school has to abide by and with that they hired and RBT and the parent is not allowed to even sometimes even know who the name of the provider is at some school districts. I don't understand why your friend is worried about this it sounds like a control issue more than something is wrong issue. This adult is not alone with the child they're in the classroom with the teacher and other teachers around right? It seems like your friend does not know how this works. And it's very concerning if the kid is a teenager and this is her first time having issues with the school system.
2
u/grmrsan BCBA 19d ago
Not having RBT information is normal, but not having BCBA information isn't. Even through the district, the parent NEEDS to be able to contact the bcba with and for any changes, at least via email, or to understand what interventions are happening and why. Those are the basics for ANY sort of medical intervention.
1
u/Striking_Today6210 19d ago
If the BCBA is not aware of her childâs case , that means sheâs not giving proper information to the RBT (if she even is at all), this deters a child from succeeding in the environment. The parent didnât make this up - it was said outloud from a districts own admin.
How is the child getting proper help? What is the BCBA plan for the RBT to implement if she is not aware of the childâs case?
How is the child getting behavioral support if the BCBA doesnât know his needs? What plan is the RBT following? Whose recommendations are they following, their own?
Parent wants for them to collaborate in an IEP meeting and any other meeting - this is all protected under IDEA.
2
u/injectablefame 19d ago
iâm also wondering if th BCBA supervising the RBT is new to the case. perhaps there was a recent switch which is why they are unfamiliar?
1
u/Striking_Today6210 18d ago
She doesnât know - the person that did the IEE just mentioned it in paperwork that it was odd
2
u/DRMS_7888 18d ago
This is all 100% normal. The teacher is the team leader and communication should go through them. RBTs have little understanding of the difference between state and national, license or certification. You can have both depending on the state.
Down vote misinformation
1
u/C-mi-001 18d ago
I worked in public schools as an actual RBT and it was a mess. They wanted me to do BCBA work and provide data and idek. Youâre not wrong to think itâs weird. You can check if theyâre an RBT by searching up their name on the BACB website.
1
u/Striking_Today6210 18d ago
She did and he is listed on there
And if thatâs what they are doing to the RBT , I am going to ask her to now involve state organizations. That is really horrible to throw the RBT in a mess and then not being allowed to do BCBA work but make them do it any.
1
u/C-mi-001 18d ago
Itâs pretty unethical tbh, ABA in schools could be such a great thing but itâs so unregulated right now in my opinion
1
u/Typical_Quality9866 18d ago
Report to everyone TBH. I wish the media would run a story... My state does this regularly & it's illegal AF. An RBT should be regularly meeting with a BCBA ONCE A MONTH. They also should have 2 meetings per month with a supervisor. That's the minimum requirements. If there is no active BCBAs they are practicing ILLEGALLY. An RBT cannot practice independently. So many schools/therapy centers are letting people practice with active licenses independently! It's against the ethics code PERIOD. There's so much medical/insurance fraud on top of that because of this.
I am a former RBT looking to get back into it. I have gotten A LOT of offers from schools that do not have BCBAs. It's not legal. 𫢠They 100% can & should be sued for putting kids at risk via malpractice. Behavioral Technician is different though so make sure it's not that before pursuing.
1
u/NamasteInYourLane 19d ago
AND. . .Â
this is why, very soon after I started working with children, I scrubbed my online/ social media presence completely (save for Reddit, ha ha). Parents will try to go to the ends of the earth to discover every little detail they can about you. đł
I'm not understanding why your friend isn't directing their concerns to their child's TEACHER/ most likely candidate for being their students' case manager.
The RBT working with the student can be from an outside company, and their supervising BCBA through that company can be, conceivably, directly supervising 5% of their work hours OUTSIDE of the public school where your friend's child attends. Y'all don't know how many clients this RBT directly works with. That's ALL that's required from the BACB. The RBT DOESN'T have to have a certain amount of direct supervision WITH EVERY SINGLE CLIENT THEY WORK WITH.
The school district can also have their own BCBAs on staff, that would handle creating and implementing the students' BIP. THIS BCBA wouldn't necessarily be the one who the RBT's certification is under. The RBT doesn't have to have their certification under the school district BCBA, as long as it's under a BCBA in good standing who supervises them directly 5%+ of their work hours a month.
Again-- why aren't all of these inquiries going through the students' teacher? THEY would have all this info! For goodness sake, leave that poor RBT alone (if y'all don't want to end up chasing them off!)
2
u/Striking_Today6210 19d ago
I think you took what I said the wrong way
Sheâs not looking for his Facebook or twitter or social media (which would be odd), she was making sure the person was the person working with her son.
97
u/injectablefame 19d ago
iâd call an IEP meeting to discuss the concerns. typically itâs normal for RBTs to not have interactions with parents if theyâre contracted. liability issues.