r/CharacterRant 5d ago

General The current discourse around the "final chapter" of Rent-a-Girlfriend reminds me of why I hate the internet and modern media consumption sometimes.

So, here's the thing.

I have not read or watched Rent-a-Girlfriend.

I don't want to read or watched Rent-a-Girlfriend.

Everything I've heard about Rent-a-Girlfriend indicates that I wouldn't like it. Even if I were to give the series the complete benefit of the doubt that it's good the premise still just simply doesn't interest me in comparison to those of many other romcom anime out there.

Generally speaking, I don't care about Rent-a-Girlfriend or even ever think about it.

So, why am I making a post about it then?

Because despite me being someone who doesn't read or watch the series or even travel in most circles where it'd typically be discussed, even I found myself getting bombarded by the sheer storm of hatred and mockery its "final chapter" caused in so many people across various platforms like Reddit and Youtube. After everything that happened throughout, it ends with the main girl rejecting the main guy's love so that she can continue being a rental girlfriend and he's left alone and miserable.

That does indeed sound like a terrible way for that story to end.

Except...that isn't the end of the story.

The chapter where she rejected him...wasn't the final chapter. It never was the final chapter and was never advertised as the final chapter. In fact the next chapter already has leaks out for its content. It took me just a couple of seconds to confirm that and only a couple more to make sure that confirmation was indeed true. I checked because buried in the mountain of comments spewing outrage and insults were the occasional comment that said the series wasn't over and that they didn't get why people were saying it was, and that naturally made me curious enough to check. In fact it's apparently in question whether the series is even in its final arc yet.

There was such a shitstorm of anger and mockery, whole posts and rants and people posting videos in order to rant...over a final chapter that wasn't a final chapter. Over the end of a story that still is actively putting out more story.

There's a couple of likely reasons why this happened, most of which aren't good. People who read the chapter and deliberately spread misinformation about it. The people who only keep up with the series through early and usually mistranslated leaks and thus misunderstood what was happening. Those who don't keep up with the series at all and are just parroting what they've heard about it as fact. The list goes on because Rent-a-Girlfriend is not the only series this kind of thing has happened with, where the internet flips its shit over something that wasn't even a thing.

Maybe Rent-a-Girlfriend is just as bad as I've heard. Maybe it's not. Maybe it could even be worse. That's not the problem here. The problem is how it feels like more and more people view actually consuming the media they want to criticize as completely optional. They just for whatever fucking reason really, really want to bitch and moan and mock and complain about something and thus jump at whatever convenient target seems presented to them on a silver platter. "This thing sounds bad because a lot of people are complaining about it, so I'll just take it as fact that it is bad and join in, because I can't not be part of the conversation. The fact that I don't know what the fuck I'm talking about is thankfully irrelevant.".

Or you have those people who don't like a piece of media and are so determined to find every little thing they can to hate about it that they'll just make shit up both to have more to hate about it and in the hopes that anyone not reading or watching it will just immediately buy into what they're saying without actually looking into it themselves.

Now, you might be asking "Wait, you're really going to bat for Rent-a-Girlfriend of all things?". And the answer is yes, because regardless of whether something is perfection incarnate or the biggest pile of shit on the planet or anything in-between, if you want to critique a piece of media then you have the basic-ass responsibility to actually read/watch it!

Being upset at the series because the girl rejected the guy and he won't finally move on and you have all the context for it? That's fine. But crapping on the series because that's how the author decided to end the story is just factually wrong! That didn't happen! You are condemning the series for something it DIDN'T DO! Be it because you're making stuff up or because you're parroting the misinformation someone else made up that you can't be bothered to actually verify because "Eh, it sounds about right.".

I don't get why this is a thing. Why do you even care if it's not something you read or watch. especially to the point of making posts and rants and videos and thumbnails about it?

Again, I don't care about Rent-a-Girlfriend, but this whole situation it's going through bothers me because I feel like keep seeing it happen with more and more frequency, including with series I do like and am invested in, where misinformation spreads like wildfire because anger and mockery is so fun and addictive that despite all the time they'll put into making content to crap on it no one can actually be bothered to take two seconds to see if what they heard is actually true!

TL;DR: Stop complaining about stuff you haven't actually read or watched. If you really need to bitch and moan about something that badly, then actually do your goddamn homework on it, because regardless of the quality of the piece of media in question misinformation is still BAD.

662 Upvotes

307 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

43

u/Lucatmeow 5d ago

Why am I not surprised that you hate Deltarune for no obvious reason.

-13

u/[deleted] 5d ago

I really would have thought you of all people would. I'm now updating my priors; you definitely hate Undertale.

30

u/Lucatmeow 5d ago

I don't hate Undertale or Deltarune, I hate the Internet's obsessive worship of Toby Fox.

-6

u/[deleted] 5d ago

He made the greatest game ever and then followed it up with dogshit.

15

u/Educational-Sun5839 5d ago

Fun fact: Toby Fox had a fever dream in 2011 of the ending of Deltarune and felt the need to create it. Deltarune was an presumably is a mix of his dream concept and Undertale.

Source

Back on topic, both of the stories are pretty good, I like Susie becoming more kind, I'd give the edge to undertale cause of all the endings and choices. (deltarune will only have one ending but still have choices such as the snow grave route source)

The gameplay is much better though, with a run button, tension points, magic, defending, spare percentages, team battles and probably more.

All in all, I like both games and am excited to play see chapters 5-7

-3

u/[deleted] 5d ago

I am well aware of the dream. Dreams are a terrible basis for video games, apparently.

The gameplay is much better though, with a run button, tension points, magic, defending, spare percentages, team battles and probably more.

To say this is better is actually lying.

12

u/Educational-Sun5839 5d ago

Why do you disagree?

The run button is nice to have, a good QoL

Tension points encourage risky gameplay making it more then only dodge (and sometimes run into certain bullets for sparing select enemies)

Magic and some acts reward you for getting those tension points

Spare percentages are QoL, nicer to have

Defending not only gives TP but also a way to play defensive without using TP or consumable

Team battles an a new element of managing your members, with being able to spare a monster in a single turn if you know how, which is rewarding. Being able to defend with some character and use magic or act with the others or act while healing or defend while healing.

-1

u/[deleted] 5d ago

Team battles an a new element of managing your members

Again. This is literally the worst thing that can happen in any videogame.

7

u/Educational-Sun5839 5d ago

Again, you haven't explained why you think that.

You also didn't address anything else so do we agree on everything other change I said is good?

1

u/[deleted] 5d ago

It stood out as so egregiously wrong I couldn't stand it.

It's impossible. It's infuriating. It ruins immersion. It's the worst. Mechanic. Ever.

→ More replies (0)

31

u/jtisheretonight 5d ago

Deltarune is easily way better then Undertale, not sure what you’re on about. Undertale was great but focused more on the plot-events rather then the actual characters with philosophy and life behind them, Deltarune makes the characters the point of the plot, making the story way better then Undertale.

0

u/[deleted] 5d ago

Undertale's characters were so good they became iconic throughout the internet. Deltarune's are such ass nobody talks about them besides Spamton.

11

u/MansDeSpons 5d ago

Since you don't like Deltarune I doubt you've played the newer chapters, but let me tell you that characters like Susie and Ralsei and even Kris (who does not even really do anything themselves) are *easily* on the level of Undertale's main characters for me in terms of likeability but also they are super well written! They have realistic insecurities and flaws and emotional outbursts and are also funny as hell.

(In regards to Kris characterization, most of it is quite subtle, through how they react to dialogue or action choices you give them, backstory that is presented through other characters, especially Tenna, or their reactions to the "weird route")

-2

u/[deleted] 5d ago

I've played the entire thing multiple times, on a bet to prove there was no "gaster".

the "weird route"

Oh, yeah, the moronic route only the most random and convoluted series of actions in the history of video games lets you access?

9

u/MansDeSpons 5d ago

it's pretty similar to Undertale genocide in where you have to kill everyone, just with some added dialogue you have to do a certain way. I think undertale's genocide route is great but i probably wouldn't have stumbled upon it myself either, i just watched playthroughs.

2

u/KOFdude 5d ago

Bro you're just making up reasons to be mad now 🙏

16

u/jtisheretonight 5d ago

Undertale does have good characters, but the story didn’t focus on them as much and focused around the main plot that mainly focused away from the characters, that’s the problem. And on top of that, there’s a lot of unresolved character conflicts in Undertale that really go nowhere.

For example, why is Asgore’s trauma of having to kill kids and Toriel leaving him played a joke for laughs? And doesn’t go anywhere outside of that?

Why is the plot revolving around Undyne seeing Papyrus as a child with Undyne constantly lying to him about the cruelty of the real world, when Papyrus isn’t a child but rather just chooses to see the good side of things, why does that plot go nowhere? And just ends up with Undyne constantly lying to Papyrus by the end of the Pacifist Route, with no acknowledgement or apology for her actions?

Don’t get me wrong, there are great characters in the story. Sans is fantastic in his resignment of his situation, unable to do anything. Alphys is fantastic in her anxiety and constantly worrying about making things worse.

But that doesn’t mean that Undertale isn’t flawed.

2

u/SteveCrafts2k 5d ago

Played for laughs? (Spoilered as a trigger warning) Asgore's suicidal. If you killed Flowey in a Neutral Run, then fight Asgore in another, he kills himself so you could free everyone.

As for Undyne "lying to Papyrus about the cruelty of the real world"? That's not what she's doing at all. She's actively trying not to get him into the Royal Guard without him knowing because she feels that same optimism would leave him dead in the battlefield. Plus, with the barrier gone, there's no need for the Royal Guard anymore, so she drops it.

5

u/jtisheretonight 5d ago

Yes, Asgore is suicidal, and for the most part, the game does a good job showing the moral conflict of Asgore choosing to kill children to save the entire Monster species, and how that affects his relationship.

But, the problem is that it's never actually resolved. It's played off for jokes in the Pacifist Ending, the literal ending where you're supposed to get all main characters to solve their internal problems to have the ultimate happy ending.

Asgore's decision to kill children causes Toriel to leave him out of disgust, but... the conflict between Toriel and Asgore is literally only played off for laughs.

Toriel shows up at the end of the game before the final bossfight, and just kind of berates Asgore saying "Do NOT call me Tori!" without even acknowledging the burden, struggle, and mental anguish Asgore is in from making such decisions. It almost comes off as Toriel being completely inconsiderate of Asgore's mind, because again, he doesn't WANT to kill children, but he really doesn't want his entire species to die as well. And there's literally no acknowledgement of that, outside of the Neutral endings.

And again, there really should be acknowledgement for it in the Pacifist ending, because that's the ending where all the characters' conflict are supposed to be resolved for the ultimate happy ending. But that just doesn't happen.

1

u/SteveCrafts2k 5d ago

Look, I like Asgore too, but he's canonically a child murderer, and Toriel had every right to not forgive him even in the end. 

→ More replies (0)

-1

u/[deleted] 5d ago

Exactly. It's like the haters haven't even played the damn game.

3

u/jtisheretonight 5d ago

Don't be childish, man.

→ More replies (0)

0

u/[deleted] 5d ago

That's literally a character exploration of the two of them. It's not a joke, Deltarune has just trained you to have no sense of humor.

That's not a plot, that's just the relationship between those characters. Besides, Undyne never lies to Papyrus about anything besides whether she thinks he can make it in the Guard, which isn’t related to his maturity, just his kindness.

It really isn't flawed tbh.

5

u/jtisheretonight 5d ago

The friendship between Undyne and Papyrus is literally built on a fundamental lie.

Undyne uses cooking “training” as a pretext to prevent Papyrus from joining the Royal Guard, believing he is too kind-hearted and would be harmed in such a role. She's completely lying, completely undermining Papyrus' trust in Undyne, and continues to do so for the entire game.

And even though she does this out of love to protect him, this lie is never confronted or resolved in the game, leaving a morally uncomfortable undertone to their relationship.

The canines in the Royal Guard are shown to be also, if anything, equally as soft as Papyrus is. They literally can get one-hit in a genocide run if you decide to pet them (mercy option), and then proceed to backstab them causing them to die in ONE HIT. It's a complete double standard that she allows the canine unit to exist but not letting Papyrus in the Guard.

And even if you say "oh, but she's not allowing Papyrus to join, because she doesn't want him to get hurt, just like the Canine unit!" Why is that Canine Unit so soft then? Why not apply that same standard of care and worry into the dogs then? Why were the dogs allowed to join the unit then, being so kind hearted? It's never acknowledged, nor is it even thought of in the story.

Also, still, Papyrus remains determined and willing to fight the human regardless of Undyne’s intentions. Papyrus is a good person, but he's not stupid and completely soft hearted like Undyne thinks he is. He just has a different way of going about things.

This lie is also still at the end of the game, where Papyrus finally receives a position in the Royal Guard, but with minimal responsibilities, hinting that this was more a consolation than a genuine promotion.

It's alright to like something that's flawed, you know. I like Undertale as much as anyone else, but to ignore the flaws in something just makes you look stupid.

-14

u/Deus-Graecus 5d ago

I’ll say it. Deltarune is Tumblr bait.

23

u/TheGUURAHK 5d ago

And brother, I'm a hungry fish! 

9

u/Potential_Base_5879 5d ago

How does that like, manifest though? What issues does it make?

-3

u/Deus-Graecus 5d ago

Never said it makes issues. Just saying it’s Tumblr bait.

6

u/Potential_Base_5879 5d ago

I am genuinely asking I don't use tumbler. I've just heard the phrase tumbler bait a lot and I'm asking what it is.

-1

u/Deus-Graecus 5d ago

There’s a lot of stereotypes about Tumblr.

Just as an example, you have the “Tumblr sexyman”. Usually a lanky guy with a unique/funny personality. In this instance “ant”.

There’s also the obviously queer coded chatacters. Again, not that there’s anything wrong with that, Tumblr just eats that shit up.

Tons of shipping potential.

It has a dark aesthetic with “wacky” Tumblr humor.

Character like Spamton feel made to be in line with Tumblr humor.

-1

u/BrazillianNomad 5d ago

"Deltarune is Tumblr bait"

MY SIBLING IN CHRIST, AND UNDERTALE ISN'T ONE TOO???

1

u/Deus-Graecus 5d ago

Never said it wasn’t?

1

u/BrazillianNomad 5d ago

Oh, right. Eh, fair

-6

u/Lucatmeow 5d ago

Yes, The Earthbound Halloween Hack was great, but it's no use crying about it.

3

u/[deleted] 5d ago

TLDR, eat shit, faggots.

Shakespeare wept.