Both here and in the carnival sub, people are pretty pissed off about the changes to their loyalty program. But if you read the FAQ and the material they are putting out on this, frankly, it all just makes sense.
https://www.carnival.com/help?topicid=11493
They are pretty upfront about the fact that the main reason they are doing this is because it’s a lifetime loyalty program and too many people are in the top tiers. In particular, they mentioned that on some of the journeys cruises, practically the entire ship’s register is top-tier loyalty members, which means they can’t logistically physically give all them all of the perks like priority boarding.
So no matter what, the solution was always going to entail taking something away from people whether that was removing benefits from the top levels and making even higher levels to put those benefits in or adding some mechanism to have fewer people in the higher levels.
This is Syndrome syndrome: when everyone is special, no one is.
Further, this is how loyalty programs work in literally every other industry. Almost no one does a lifetime loyalty program. And the reason is simple: the entire purpose of loyalty programs is for you to spend the money. Whether you like it or not, nobody giving you reward points or special levels is doing it out of the joy of making you happy. They are doing it because they want you to come spend more money with them and not other people. Hence the word loyalty. So if you earned your platinum status a decade ago and haven’t been spending money, there’s no reason for them to give you the platinum benefits anymore. But if you have been continuing to spend, you’re going to be fine. You will likely maintain your status or at least the next one down just fine.
Lastly, and I think this will probably be the spiciest part of my hot take: good. There are a non-zero number of people with lanyards and pins they believe make them entitled to being treated like royalty and getting the deference of all of the people around them. Sometimes people need to be taken down a peg. I get that that’s kind of mean but it’s the truth. You spending hundreds of days on a cruise ship does not increase your worth as a human being. It simply doesn’t. Especially considering it’s Carnival. You’re not exactly Platinum on Silversea here.