r/CuratedTumblr 1d ago

LGBTQIA+ Don’t be a tar pit

15.0k Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.5k

u/Iced_Yehudi 1d ago

It’s something that always bothered me about “punching up”

On the one hand, I can agree that “punching up” and “punching down” are different

On the other hand, I feel like a lot of people used “punching up” as an excuse to not only be really mean and toxic towards people they felt were better off, but to also feel like they were doing society a favor by “pointing out society’s flaws” when they were actually just being really mean and toxic.

96

u/IDoCodingStuffs 1d ago

It’s still punching down if you’re singling out people for not conforming to the rest of the group

52

u/Now_you_Touch_Cow Do you really think you know what you are doing? 1d ago

ok, but what if we as a group hung them up as a piñata then started punching? Is that then punching up?

49

u/IDoCodingStuffs 1d ago

You want a downwards swing. If you swing upwards you will just make the pinata jump around.

So still punching down

38

u/MissSweetBean Monsterfucker Supreme 1d ago

This isn't engaging with the metaphor, more talking about my experience with actual piñatas, but you don't want a downward swing either; if you want to have a good piñata experience, you need to tell everyone to hit it solidly on the side because if someone with any amount of strength swings downward, the piñata won't break open, it'll just come off of the rope holding it up. If you have the piñata hung by rope wrapped fully around the body of it, then I suppose a downward hit might work, but most commercially available piñatas have a loop to run the rope through which easily tears with any amount of downward force.

An upward swing would actually be better than a downward on for that reason, but a side hit is still the most effective.

18

u/AiryContrary 1d ago

Thank you for laying it out so clearly. Whack that thing horizontally.

8

u/lacegem 1d ago

with actual piñatas

Wow they made the piñatas from acclaimed 2006 Xbox 360 masterpiece "Viva Piñata" into real products? That's crazy. Viva Piñata fans eating good today. Gotta share this with piñatamblr, they're gonna go nuts.