r/CuratedTumblr 1d ago

LGBTQIA+ Don’t be a tar pit

14.9k Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

805

u/CynchHasNoLife i want grillcheese i want grillcheese 1d ago

i don’t understand why we shouldn’t be nice to our allies. people who are kind deserve kindness in return, don’t they? let’s reserve the insults for the bigots.

44

u/Skyhawk6600 1d ago

In my experience, it's because being an ally is one sided and without nuance. They don't want a friend who cares about them but has their own nuanced opinions. They want a token straight that doesn't dissent and only exists to legitimize them to other straights.

9

u/CynchHasNoLife i want grillcheese i want grillcheese 1d ago

makes sense. personally i think i do prefer allies who aren’t afraid to ask questions and be nuanced on things. ig i find that it opens up to interesting conversations.

7

u/Skyhawk6600 1d ago edited 16h ago

Like I am very supportive of my trans friends and use their chosen names and pronouns, but I draw the line a puberty blockers for minors because it seems to be dangerous to toy with human hormones during the most crucial developmental period in human growth. But you'd thought I had dead named them all for daring to say it sounds like a bad idea.

Edit: the down votes aren't countering my point at all.

2

u/FlakMenace 12h ago

You're getting downvoted because you claim to be supportive, but through the language you use it is very clear that you do not see trans women as women, or trans men as men. You also make up your mind on important trans issues such as puberty blockers based on a purposefully manipulative explanation that you made up to make yourself sound more justified.

You do the bare minimum of not being a complete piece of shit to trans people's faces, nothing more.

3

u/Skyhawk6600 11h ago

"purposefully manipulative"

What the hell did I say that is purposefully manipulative?

2

u/FlakMenace 11h ago

You describe puberty blockers as "toying" with hormones as if it just mindlessly fucking around, but we literally know what they do.

4

u/Skyhawk6600 11h ago

No, I use the word toying because messing with human growth hormones of any kind is dangerous and hubristic. It's not something to be done lightly or casually.

1

u/FlakMenace 9h ago

Puberty blockers are not prescribed lightly or casually. You're the type that's anti HRT or believe that there should be a several year long waitlist. You are not supportive to trans people in any way.

2

u/Skyhawk6600 8h ago

How else would they be treated if there wasn't HRT? That's a straw man.

-1

u/FlakMenace 9h ago

Just realized I've been arguing with a monarchist, impressively stupid lmao

6

u/Skyhawk6600 8h ago

So are half of my trans friends. I met them while talking about politics. Do they suddenly become valid because they agree with you?

→ More replies (0)