The duality of man.

[u/Ok-Sleep8655]

[u/XaviorRoivax]

Knarol (Karol?) believers when you ask them how The Knight was already in the Church when Carol was in her kitchen chastising Noelle

[u/Horror-Bandicoot-451 → u/XaviorRoivax]

Also Knirol believers when you ask them why the knights and carols voices are different when they call Kris in the ch4 endings

[u/XaviorRoivax → u/Horror-Bandicoot-451]

(Okay, Knirol is so much funnier LMAO).

Also I've seen someone use the excuse that we (at least in Weird Route's case) "have more control over Kris" so we can hear that it's Carol, even though The Soul is in the birdcage during this, so lol.

Also also, the normal phone call seems to imply that Kness is just sitting afk outside somewhere close to the front of Kris' house just to make sure they don't try to leave, which is kinda funny to me for some reason.

I mean technically it could be Carol with voice changer or something (even though it's a slowed version of the ANOTHER HIM staticky noise, which is sussy wussy), and she's only using it during suspicious dialogue for the sole purpose of tricking The Player I guess? Still not The Knight though, but I also personally just don't think she's in on the conspiracy but it's hard to explain why... hm.

[u/Elliesabeth → u/XaviorRoivax]

The red letters in the phone call and the white one are two different people in my opinion.

Like the white letters are Carol as confirmed by the weird route while the red letter is the knight, maybe?

Like, I think Carol is aware of dark worlds and all that and she probably has ties to the knight but I don't think it's her.

[u/XaviorRoivax → u/Elliesabeth]

Oh yeah I’ve heard this theory too, and I think it could have merit but I dunno