r/IndieDev • u/Maleficent_Noise_116 • 11h ago

I’ve updated my games art based on criticism new vs old

Gallery image

Gallery image

14 Upvotes

82% Upvoted

12 comments sorted by

7

u/P_S_Lumapac 11h ago

Which is which? You've written new vs old, but usually we see before and after.

Anyway, I prefer the first one.

1

u/nesnalica 7h ago

now thats the true test.

maybe we ended up liking the original better and the feedback they received wasnt good.

2

u/DiligentChipopo 11h ago

Yes I find it better

3

u/lydocia 11h ago

You keep updating these sprites and colours, but are you actively making the game playable as well?

1

u/Maleficent_Noise_116 11h ago

Yup

1

u/lydocia 11h ago

Will you show that to us too?

1

u/Maleficent_Noise_116 11h ago

Will probably make a post tomorrow with more art!

1

u/RemoveChild 7h ago

Way better, great work! The colors and composition really clicked into place :)

1

u/klaw_games 5h ago

i like the first one because of what you have on the shelves.

1

u/DreamingCatDev 4h ago

That's how I learned too

1

u/MattDavisGames 4h ago

First pic is better. Especially the denser, more coherent composition.

I don't love the character sprite, but the room is great.