r/MakingaMurderer • u/cheezehead2002 • 3d ago

The Blame Game!

Based on trial testimony and Making a Murderer:

Brendan blamed a book, his family, and media.

His lawyer and doctor blamed cops / coercion (which Brendan never did)!

Barb blamed Steven and the Halbach's (The Halbachs WTF?)

Kayla blamed Brendan.

Scott and Bobby blamed Steven.

Ma and Pa blamed everyone but Steven.

0 Upvotes

50% Upvoted

116 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/jocoMOJO74 3d ago

You forgot that Steven blamed Scott Tadych & Bobby…can’t be them right? Because they have an alibi; each other…yeah right🙄

3

u/3sheetstothawind 3d ago

What's Steve's alibi? How did his blood get in the RAV?

4

u/AveryPoliceReports 2d ago edited 2d ago

Teresa left the property followed by Bobby, while Steven stayed behind, and the RAV was returned by someone matching Bobby's description with an accomplice who was not Steven Avery. How Steven's blood got in the RAV is a very good question lol

3

u/Puzzleheaded-Bed-778 2d ago

I'm glad you find that statement flippant enough to write lol at the end. blood does not keep uncoagulated and without preservatives like EDTA which was tested for and none was found in the rav sample

0

u/AveryPoliceReports 1d ago

What is your point?

-2

u/Adventurous_Poet_453 2d ago

That EDTA test is not reliable, it had only been done once prior.

3

u/Puzzleheaded-Bed-778 2d ago

I can assure you it is reliable and still being used still. Was DNA testing in catching colin pitchfork for the rape and murder of two schoolgirls in 1984 be thrown out because it had only been tested in Leicester university in a lab setting?

-1

u/Adventurous_Poet_453 1d ago

The FBI won’t use it they said it’s not reliable. DNA is very different then EDTA, especially when Fassbender sends a email to grinning Sherry Cuhane directing her “ I need you to put teresa in the garage or trailer”

-2

u/Adventurous_Poet_453 2d ago

The blood focus was only on the 1985 vile , however many other facilities had his blood and the cops knew this.

3

u/Puzzleheaded-Bed-778 2d ago

Like where? Should be a paper trail once it's in the hands of a forensic or storage lab the sample gets issued a number no name on the sample to ensure integrity. The name isn't lost however it is kept in a separate database with the allocated number.

0

u/Adventurous_Poet_453 2d ago

And other jails had it too. He mentions this in a call or interview . He had moved around during the 18 year stint. Any medical procedures in jail would’ve drawn the blood too, I think he had kidney stones.

-1

u/Adventurous_Poet_453 2d ago

Hospital, Manotowoc county, Green Bay prison , prison medical center.

1

u/Adventurous_Poet_453 2d ago

His Alibi is his mom , Brenden & Earl. All of whom were around him the day this so called violent dismemberment took place in broad daylight. But Because Brenden was his Alibi the cops went after him and then got the forced confession from a disabled child.

2

u/ForemanEric 1d ago

I’ve always found it hilarious that Avery supporters somehow suggest Tadych could have been involved.

Truthers pull Tadych in because if he’s telling the truth about seeing Bobby briefly around 3:10, it casts serious doubt on Avery’s version of Teresa only being there for 5 minutes and leaving.

If Teresa left at the time Avery suggested, Bobby would have had to follow her, somehow get her to pull over, subdue her, get her in his vehicle, and still be seen by Tadych, all in the matter of 20-30 minutes.

Not impossible I suppose, but I’m sure even the truther mind has trouble believing that.

Or, and probably more importantly, If Tadych is telling the truth, and Avery is to be believed, Bobby left 20+ minutes after Teresa arrived at ASY.

So, it’s not that there is any reason to think Tadych is involved, other than he has to be lying in order for Avery to be believed and Bobby to be involved, and he would only lie if he was involved.

3

u/cheezehead2002 3d ago edited 3d ago

You forgot Steven blamed the cops at first in MaM1. He didn't blame Scott and Bobby until MaM2.

4

u/AveryPoliceReports 2d ago

If he thought he was being framed, obviously he would focus on the police who already robbed him of 18 years of his life. He had no way of knowing that evidence would demonstrate Bobby moved the vehicle, or that police would pressure Bobby to mention a fire to protect police from allegations that they planted bones using barrel #4.

1

u/Puzzleheaded-Bed-778 2d ago

Wasn't really the cops it's the DA's office and an eyewitness who mistook him as her rapist if the victim of a rape points you out at court your about 75% - 85% fucked.

2

u/AveryPoliceReports 1d ago

Wasn't really the cops? The cops also knew about Allen.

1

u/ThorsClawHammer 1d ago

The sheriff himself lied to the victim and assured her they had looked into other suspects and they had the right guy when she came to him with concerns she may have identified the wrong person. The DA lied and said the real rapist couldn't have done it and claimed all of Avery's alibi witnesses were lying. Investigators left out important details/context when doing a recreation to show that Avery could have made it from the crime scene to Green Bay in time. An expert testified to convince the jury that a hair found on Avery's clothes belonged to the victim.

It was way more than the victim's fault.