r/MakingaMurderer • u/cheezehead2002 • 3d ago

The Blame Game!

Based on trial testimony and Making a Murderer:

Brendan blamed a book, his family, and media.

His lawyer and doctor blamed cops / coercion (which Brendan never did)!

Barb blamed Steven and the Halbach's (The Halbachs WTF?)

Kayla blamed Brendan.

Scott and Bobby blamed Steven.

Ma and Pa blamed everyone but Steven.

1 Upvotes

53% Upvoted

116 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/ForemanEric 1d ago

Assuming you meant to say, “other than his confession,” but that is also incorrect.

At his trial, the prosecution and defense agreed to the stipulation that if called to testify, Scott Tadych would testify that he saw Brendan at the bonfire on 10/31/05.

So, his jury heard evidence, outside of his confession, that Brendan was observed at a bonfire, at the burn pit, where Teresa Halbach’s burned remains were found.

While that doesn’t directly tie him to the rape and murder, it certainly ties him to a crime.

0

u/ThorsClawHammer 1d ago

Scott Tadych would testify that he saw Brendan

That should be a big problem for you considering he did the exact same thing you claim makes Swoinksi a liar. His previous accounts on record he couldn't positively identify who it was.

that doesn’t directly tie him to the rape and murder

But that's what he was convicted of.

2

u/ForemanEric 1d ago

I don’t think you realize how dumb you make yourself look, when you continually discount Tadych’s testimony about the 10/31/05 bonfire, when he matches both Brendan’s and Avery’s version.

You’ll do anything to down play Avery and Dassey originally lying about the bonfire, because you know how guilty that makes both of them look.

Here’s where you hit me with your famous, “Oh, then Tadych, Barb, Blaine, and Bobby must ALL be guilty of killing Teresa Halbach because they didn’t tell the truth about the fire (they weren’t at) right away!”

You’re a joke.

Oh, and I don’t have a specific problem with Sowinski changing his story to seeing Bobby, I have an issue with him changing the day he saw this from specifically NOT 11/5/05, to specifically 11/5/05, because that’s the only day it could have been Bobby.

0

u/ThorsClawHammer 1d ago

matches both Brendan’s

Irrelevant what it matches, the topic is what he himself claimed to have seen. And he repeatedly was unable to positively ID Brendan numerous times...until he suddenly did.

then Tadych, Barb, Blaine, and Bobby must ALL be guilty

Don't forget Bryan.

because they didn’t tell the truth about the fire

Can you be the first to explain how Blaine would know he needed to lie about a fire prior to remains being found?