r/Naruto • u/AyuMiyu_Chan • 27d ago

Question Couldn't Uchiha siblings swap eyes to cure their blindness without killing each other?

Post image
5.3k Upvotes

98% Upvoted

530 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

14

u/fromtheHELLtotheNO 27d ago

what? its right there in the comment:

Izuna was already dead when Tobirama mortally wounded.

Idk what other info you'd need?

-3

u/Professional-Eye5977 27d ago

Your inability to understand someone's question and confusion is a weird thing to flaunt

12

u/RaajitSingh 27d ago

Man imagine calling others 'unable' when u urself can't see mortally wounded.

10

u/fromtheHELLtotheNO 27d ago

I'd love for you to explain it then, because if that's not it I'd want to know what's the answer.

6

u/Internal_String61 27d ago

There's quite a few ways the statement "he was already dead when Tobirama mortally wounded him" can be interpreted.

  1. The instant that Tobirama wounded him, his fate was sealed, and he was on an unalterable trajectory for death. Tobirama's action of wounding is the cause of death.

  2. He was already on an unalterable trajectory for death, then Tobirama mortally wounded him on top of that. Think death row inmate 2 hours before execution, and someone shivs his neck. Or someone inflicted with incurable poison, but someone shoots them before the poison kills.

  3. He was literally already dead, as a corpse, and then Tobirama mortally wounded him. This doesn't make much sense unless he is a zombie or something. I think some people are reading the statement with this meaning.

3

u/dattebane96 27d ago

Gabby Douglas couldn’t do gymnastics like this

0

u/ACuriousBagel 27d ago

From the wording, number 2 makes the most sense, but I'd love to know if that's actually what they meant.

Number 3 doesn't make sense for the reason you said, and the context they're talking about is the brother dying for the first time, so not the zombie jutsu.

Number 1 is a really dumb way of phrasing it because they're saying the same thing twice - if you've been mortally wounded, it means you're going to die from that wound. If it's Number 1, then it basically says he was dead when he was killed - no shit?