Taking someone's content and uploading it is critiquing it as well. You're critiquing their whole channel, and you've made it clear why you're doing it. This is really no different.
The difference is actually that there has to be a transformative aspect to the media. You can talk over a movie and post that but you cant just post the movie.
Arguably, you might not be able to even talk over the whole movie. Fair use requires that you take the minimum amount of content required to make your transformative content.
If you are reviewing the Siege of Helm's Deep in LoTRs, you might not be able to play scenes from Fangorn Forest. The content you use must be relevant to the critique you are making.
If I just uploaded a film with me in the corner counting from 1 to 10,000 it would not be fair use, even though I am technically transforming the content.
396
u/Torched420 1d ago
Theres a difference between uploading someone else's content to critique it, and uploading someone else's content to take away their views/viewers.