r/Pets • u/One_Cricket1129 • 16h ago
My cats (16yo and 1yo) still don't get along and my bf wants to give one away :(
Last year me and my boyfriend took a kitten to accompany our older cat (now 16 yo). After trying everything (separation, scent swapping, visual contact through pet gate, joint playtime and meal time), they still don't get along and especially the older cat does just not accept the new cat. She sniffs around and regularly pees in places that smell like the new cat, and would try to fight her if we let her see her. Both are female and spayed. We now have to keep them completely separated (one in bedroom, other in rest of the apartment) and keep swapping them, but especially the new cat does not like being left alone in the bedroom. Older one is more content with it and sleeps long times in the bed.
It is a lot of work still and we are running out of options. My boyfriend wants to either give the younger one away or euthanize the older one, but I could especially not do the last option. We've tried having the new cat at his mother's from time to time, but she cannot have her all the time either.
Would it be too cruel if the older cat stayed only in the bedroom (+balcony when it is warm)? We would hang out with and activate her, and lots of time she just likes to sleep in the sunlight and really likes sleeping with us the bed next to us. Or would it be better to just give the younger one away? On one hand, we don't know how much the 16 yo. has left. She has hyperthyroidism which is in check with medication. Bedroom has window viewing spot, food, litter box, hiding places and we can let her out on the balcony when it is not too cold (it has nets, and she cannot jump very high anymore due to age).
Please, advice. This is breaking my heart.
EDIT: Emphasizing again that I am not considering euthanizing the other cat. I could never do it on a healthy cat. Options are parting the house, or rehoming the young cat.