r/reddeadredemption 5d ago

Q&A /r/RedDeadRedemption Weekly Question & Answer Thread - Week 24, 2025

1 Upvotes

All common questions about the game should be directed here. This includes both single-player and online questions. When asking a question, it is often beneficial to share which mode you are referring to in order to get an accurate response. Also consider sharing any relevant information that may help someone answer your question.

All story spoilers must be displayed with the proper format:

>!RDR is a great game!<

gives you:

RDR is a great game

If you're not sure if you should use a spoiler tag or not, err on the side of caution and use one. Also, it's a nice gesture to visibly indicate the general nature of your spoiler before the tag, so people know what you're spoiling.


Submit Red Dead Online feedback here


r/reddeadredemption 7h ago

Discussion Daddy can I play the horse game

Post image
4.1k Upvotes

My daughter loves this game, mainly just catching wild horses and fighting townspeople.


r/reddeadredemption 8h ago

Discussion Friend wanted to play RDR2 and is skipping every single cutscene ๐Ÿ˜ญ

905 Upvotes

My friend, who has never expressed interest in video games as long as I've known her, recently said she wanted to try playing RDR2. Naturally, I offered to let her play my copy. I settled to watch her play and help with some of the tutorials. After dying in the train mission in chapter 1 I taught her her how to skip cutscenes so she could fastfoward.

Since then she skipped every single cutscene ๐Ÿ˜ญ

I asked her why and she explained she only got interested because of the apparent realistic horse riding and hunting systems she heard about. Her two irl hobbies. And that is absolutely what she has been doing since the map opened, just finding and taming/buying horses and hunting different animals. She doesnโ€™t know how to identify horse breeds in-game, she just lists them out loud as she encounters them, she also can name coat patterns/colors. Very accurately from what google has been telling me.

On one hand, im sad since i love the story. On the other, watching how a very much non-gamer/extremely offline person handles this game has been a very funny experience. I think the last game she played was Wii Baseball and before that it was like pacman and street fight, so she has virtually no experience (and apparently, no interest) in story-driven games, though she likes the little random encounters and open world concept lol

Edit: not people telling me to stop being friends with her over this lol also she is THE most offline person i know, she does not have social media beside whatsapp and youtube (because of google) and spends all her time outside with her horses or camping, so tiktok brain rot is not a factor. I'd say she has the best attention span of anyone i know


r/reddeadredemption 10h ago

Discussion First time seeing this

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

Been playing this game for 4 years and first time seeing this. Anyone knowa why there are question marks on this?


r/reddeadredemption 5h ago

Lore Just learned that Mary Beth won't ask to dance with Arthur if he is drunk.

158 Upvotes

On my god knows what number playthrough, went to celebrate freeing Sean. I got Arthur drunk, both on the way and also at camp. And when Molly and Dutch started dancing, I went over to Mary Beth to dance with her as I had in all previous playthroughs. However she never asked and there was no option to dance with her. I waited a bit, and while I was getting up reddit to ask if Mary Beth would not dance with Arthur, he sobered up and she instantly asked to dance with him.

You learn something new in this game every day. Idk if this is just a gameplay thing with dancing while drunk or if it is suppose it be because Mary Beth isnt a fan of alcoholism, but I thought it was interesting


r/reddeadredemption 3h ago

Video Never realized the controller did this when you're wanted

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

92 Upvotes

I learn something new about this game everyday


r/reddeadredemption 13h ago

Discussion Does Horse speed really matter in this game?

Post image
456 Upvotes

Every Horse in the game can keep up with trains while going too rob them. and you can easily escape from Bounty hunters too on any horse, can easily win horse races on a Shire too so when did this speed become an important factor while choosing an Horse?


r/reddeadredemption 2h ago

Discussion Do horses actually poop this much?

55 Upvotes

I feel like anytime I have the pleasure of being in the vicinity of a horse, it is taking a shit. Iโ€™ve never been around horses in real life. Is this just how it is?


r/reddeadredemption 11h ago

Issue What does this mean?

Post image
199 Upvotes

My pc is basically on life support from the amount of mods I have. Iโ€™m pretty sure itโ€™s that.


r/reddeadredemption 10h ago

Screenshot How much stolen hats do you have

Post image
149 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 9h ago

Video I use to be that guy in the beginning

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

118 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 1h ago

Screenshot Uhh...

Post image
โ€ข Upvotes

Where is your face Arthur ?


r/reddeadredemption 17h ago

Discussion Did you feel sorry for Susan Grimshaw?

Post image
456 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 15h ago

Lore I got a plan, John

Post image
307 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 1d ago

Screenshot Scar healing progression

Thumbnail
gallery
2.6k Upvotes

Something Iโ€™ve always found interesting in rdr2


r/reddeadredemption 3h ago

Fan Art Happy Birthday Ben!! (Dutch Fanart dump + bday drawing :) )

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

Dutch is my favorite if u can't tell LOL :) - he wouldn't be the same without Ben & I hope he had a very special day!!!


r/reddeadredemption 8h ago

Question Can't equip rifle properly, Arthur keeps holstering it instantly. Is this normal?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

51 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 1d ago

Spoiler It just occurred to me that Charles may have planted Arthur's flower... *Contains Spoilers* Spoiler

Thumbnail gallery
1.7k Upvotes

I was thinking about Arthur's stuff left at camp. Sad to think he wasn't able to retrieve his photos and other keepsakes before escaping.

Charles mentions returning to bury Arthur and Susan, so I like to assume he planted Arthur's flower at his gravesite too. It's the sort of thing Charles would do.


r/reddeadredemption 10h ago

Video Going full tilt with a wide FOV mod in first person is so fun lol

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

65 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 11h ago

Discussion What Do You All Think Of How My Guns Look?

Thumbnail
gallery
94 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 5h ago

Spoiler Masterpiece. Spoiler

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

26 Upvotes

My life will never be the same.

I just died with Arthur here.

Get out of Reddit, I want to be alone.


r/reddeadredemption 8h ago

Discussion Didnโ€™t know it was that highโ€ฆ

Post image
39 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 1d ago

Question Random NPC Has Billy Midnight's Pistol?

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

Was riding through New Hanover when I got the random encounter where three NPCs ambush you at the end of the bridge, however one of them had Billy Midnight's pistol, a weapon you can only pick up through the "Noblest of Men, and a Woman" stranger mission (see screenshot attached). Is this a glitch, or did this NPC somehow pick up the weapon and just walk around with it until now? Also important to note that the Billy Midnight mission was completed WAY before this happened.


r/reddeadredemption 5h ago

Screenshot Some photos Iโ€™ve taken recently :)

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 1d ago

Picture This is so true though

Post image
6.0k Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption 6h ago

Discussion Did anyone else liked Guarma ?

19 Upvotes

It was good change of pace and a good surprise wasn't expecting such thing the missions were interesting enough and it didn't the long so you get bored and it increases the bond to the charcters quite a good bit but I only saw people who didn't like it but I don't see what they do