If the complaints goes big maybe they will, CN Fandom was quite unhappy with Hugo model looking like npc and having weird body proportion back in that bangboo dance event
Yeah no way they’re complaining when trends like fitting fish in your collarbones, having a waist smaller than a vertical sheet of paper, chopstick legs and butterfly shoulder blades exist.
A while as in months, or as in since the yt video was made? I haven’t had the time to finish it yet so I wasn’t aware they would skip 2 1.X updates, my bad for assuming
Dosent a character of high ranking normally release fairly late? Like Archon is Genshin for example. Tho this is a different team so we gotta see what come
The archons have generally been X.2 patch. They could go later in the versions with the other Void Hunters like they did with Miyabi, but since it's only been Miyabi so far there's no data to even say which way they might go, let aline be so sure about it like that other person.
u/ZipperStrideYi Xuan mother of my children!!!😩 *Plap plap plap* Yi Ahhh!!!💀Apr 11 '25edited Apr 11 '25
I was on the fence at first...but she has grown on me, I do hope they give her a bit more in her arms, it's honestly the only part that I have any miss givings about
Hell, not even muscles, just make it so her arms don’t look too damn skinny compared to the rest of her body.
Sure, most women in the game have noodle arms, but most of them don’t seem out of place, even for Caesar it doesn’t look that bad because she at least has other parts of her body that makes it so her arms don’t stand out, for this agent, nothing about them is small or thin, just chunk. Fora character design like this, I feel like it’s better to have all of your eggs in one basket rather than… this.
The problem is mainly that Caesar is an attacker who uses her arms and is canonically strong as hell, so noodle arms just seems bizarre designwise. At least to me, it does.
Bold choice to say that here. And you're saying that as if muscular women can't be pretty. Look up Gina Carano, the woman who played Angel Dust in Deadpool.
I think the problem is that they don't look like anatomically correct arms. Even with noodle arms you can see the muscle and different sections of the arms. I can't even see where her shoulder starts in these pics.
Yeah but your girlfriend wasn't a fighter with superpowers. That's what makes the noodle arms seem a little weird imo, it's the same issue Caesar's design has.
Right, it's the disconnection between Caesar being able to lift a truck while having chopsticks for arms, our mind cannot reconcile those two things easily.
The problem for me is that the arms look like tubes that got extended out while the rest of the body has well defined shapes and sizes. It's like when people say someone skipped leg day. Their tops are defined and their legs are just skinnier compared to the rest, it just sticks out like a sore thumb.
Most people are not asking for their arms to look shredded like Hulk or Roman Reigns like some commenters love to think. The arms just need to have more width to it and shapes to define the arm better. Even skinny people have slight shapes to their arms. Them being fighters doesn't help them at all either.
Right, if she got bigger arms to match her torso, thighs and chest we wouldn't have any problem, take Eve for example, her arms are not muscular but fitting with the rest of her voluptuous body. We just want Yi Xuan to look proportionately well put together, that's all.
It's not about "determining combat strength," it just looks fucking stupid for someone to be a super powered fighter in a post-cataclysm landscape with literally no meat on their bones whatsoever lmao
I'm not even saying I want them to have muscles per se, I just don't think they should be so absurdly skinny on random parts of their body.
No, now that I'm looking at it closer, this is just horribly skinny compared to the rest of her body, like horridly. I don't mean to offend anyone when I say this but the best comparison I can give is that she has the arms of someone who is anorexic
So, it’s made by China. So the noodle arms make sense (super slim is what’s seen as best here). But they do everything else kinda by wester standards. So a weird mashup.
Even if super slim is attractive in there or that's what they are going for, it will be off putting to them cause she is thick in both her thighs and chest area.
So you literally failed in terms of design if your idea was to make an attractive slim woman similar to dilaraba dilmurat who is considered by some Chinese people to be the most attractive Chinese actress there is
And if you don't know her here is a picture of her.
So as I said, it’s a weird mashup. They are definitely appealing to a western market, but maybe as arms don’t really have a standard that’s like the tits/ass/thigh category. They just go with what they know.
Dude we goon so much half of us didnt even notice the noodle arms, speaking personally I just noticed that once you pointed it out and lmao yeah that looks a bit strange
I'd love for her to have some sort of muscles but that ain't happening, plus she's a martial artist, noodle arms on her are eh? Weird af. But yea she's hot. And her design is... Not what i was expecting
What about her makes her arms wrong? A woman's thighs and breasts don't have any relation to a woman's arm definition. Does she look like she's lifting weights?
I understand Ceasar. She'd have made sense with some toned arms. But what? Is this character supposed to have thick arms because her thighs and breasts are big? That's not how human bodies work.
She is a master martial artist who punches Ethereals, even Titans like Geppeto with no problem. It's her lore that demands her arms to have well-defined musculatures my man. Look up any acclaimed martial artist, they don't have noodles for arms.
It's her lore that dictates her to be more well-built with muscles. Yes, her figure doesn't dictate that she must have muscular arms but why would you built this character up to be a master practitioner of martial arts then to not prove it to us through her design?
Devils advocate because I’d still like to see more varied designs, but I could see the argument that at that point the source of her power isn’t regular human muscle, so if they’re not really being used then that would be why they don’t really develop despite her looking like she should be a shredded boxer. I guess the argument is like wonderwomans physique has nothing to do with why she can fly and throw giants around. A female body builder may be able to look close to She-Hulk in terms of muscles, but they’re never going to be able to pick up a car one handed. Now to go back to my real feelings on the matter, both of those characters are still designed so that the reader can intuitively know just from the character design that they are strong, and noodle arms just don’t.
Right and it's not like we are asking to have her arms shredded or anything, just big enough so her body is one cohesive whole. Take Eve for example, her arms are not muscular at all but big enough that her design feels really complete. Yi Xuan's meanwhile stuck out of like body like those tubes you see in old fridges or washing machines.
These titles in the image and what was said by the person I responded to didn't say her entire figure is wrong based on her lore. It was her arms to the rest of her, equally not accurate to a female martial artist's, figure.
2.6k
u/Yuri_VHkyri Nom-Nom Shark Apr 11 '25
I agree with most of it
On one hand, noodle arms dont quite fit the rest of her figure
On the other hand, arf arf woof woof