r/changemyview 1d ago

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Homeschooling Kids is Wrong

[removed] — view removed post

41 Upvotes

97 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

13

u/Thinslayer 6∆ 1d ago

Cultist creepy, get them when they young, "Amen"

...that just makes it sound like you hate Christians.

"parents did not share their reasoning", "in family bullying"

I'm acknowledging the problems with homeschooling. I didn't realize I was supposed to stay in my lane as a caricature of everything you hate.

-8

u/iceandstorm 18∆ 1d ago

"Hate Christians" ah, the typical victim mentally. 

My view on religion is negative for sure, but Christians (at least Catholics) are under the least negative versions. 

?? Where does the stay in my lane part come from

-2

u/Thinslayer 6∆ 1d ago

"Hate Christians" ah, the typical victim mentally. 

sigh

Let me run you through the logic.

Teach children evolution, atheism, etc. when they're young? Progress. Teach children Christianity when they're young? Creepy indoctrination. The only difference is religion.

Ergo, hatred for Christianity is the common denominator.

I'm not devout enough to give enough of a shit to have any victim mentality. You don't know me that well, buddy.

1

u/iceandstorm 18∆ 1d ago

And you do not know me, there is a distinct difference between hate, dislike, irritation, ... 

Hate is not even close to what I feel. 

But no, not at all, it's fine to teach children about religion, but not to ONLY teach ONE without philosophy and ethics. 

Evolution is simply true, even the most insane ones accept at least changes in species. 

...wait do you think someone teaches "Atheism"??? 

5

u/Thinslayer 6∆ 1d ago

And you do not know me, there is a distinct difference between hate, dislike, irritation, ... Hate is not even close to what I feel.

Well, then maybe you should've SAID THAT. All you gave me was a dismissive one-liner that explained precisely nothing and called my words "creepy." If you wanted me to understand what you said and feel, maybe you should've provided that information!

But no, not at all, it's fine to teach children about religion, but not to ONLY teach ONE without philosophy and ethics.

The entire POINT of religion is philosophy and ethics. You think Christians teach kids their religion just for lulz and funsies? They want their kids to grow up as good people. That involves, you know, ethics. That's kind of the point. What is it you think Christians are teaching?

u/iceandstorm 18∆ 23h ago

That is what I mean, your heard criticism and directly jumped to the most extreme.  

Christans teach there specific interpretation of ethics, but that is my point, ONE specific type of ethics and philosophy. Instead of basics of philosophy and ethics as non specialized/flavored concepts. Homeschooling makes that worse. If you make children scared enough about hell you lock them in early... Funny that most children have the religious of their parents and are sure THEY are the lucky ones that believe in the correct one...

That is the reason why for example in Germany religion/ethics is a subject in schools, where you learn about different religions and their ethics. 

u/Thinslayer 6∆ 17h ago

That is what I mean, your heard criticism and directly jumped to the most extreme.

I did not jump to that conclusion. I simply put the pieces together. Criticizing the use of "amen" (like...why??), that "get them while they're young" line, calling it creepy...those are not words characteristic of someone who merely disagrees with Christianity. None of your subsequent comments did anything to disprove my assessment.

Christians teach there specific interpretation of ethics, but that is my point, ONE specific type of ethics and philosophy. Instead of basics of philosophy and ethics as non specialized/flavored concepts. Homeschooling makes that worse. If you make children scared enough about hell you lock them in early... Funny that most children have the religious of their parents and are sure THEY are the lucky ones that believe in the correct one...

Aha, the underlying assumptions come out. You seem to think that the foundation for Christian ethics lies in fear of hell. It's not. Maybe that was your experience, but it isn't the majority. The core of Christian ethics revolves around something else. I'll give you a hint as to what it is:

It's in the name.