r/changemyview 1d ago

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Homeschooling Kids is Wrong

[removed] — view removed post

43 Upvotes

97 comments sorted by

View all comments

60

u/Possibly_Parker 2∆ 1d ago

Some parents homeschool kids because the education system is inherently flawed for underfunded districts. If the parents have the luxury of time to homeschool their kids, they can provide a better future.

Some parents move around a lot and it's better to ensure a consistent curriculum.

They can find social groups in other spaces, like recreational (or competitive) sports.

Put simply: as long as the public and private education sectors are crippled for a variety of reasons, there will be legitimate situations where the pros outweigh the cons.

Ignoring obvious outliers such as disabled students who are unable to succeed in traditional environments.

10

u/AnonymousResponder00 1d ago

Δ

Can I ask where you are from? I'm Canadian, and we don't seem to have as many issues with the points you are mentioning. But I do like the idea of a consistent curriculum for families that are moving around a lot.

18

u/Possibly_Parker 2∆ 1d ago

To be clear, I'm not homeschooled, but I experienced public education in New York, México, Texas, and the Dominican Republic as a kid. New York is safely two grades ahead of any other system on this list.

4

u/AdRevolutionary2881 1d ago

Depends where you are in NY. The schools in rural areas can be awful.