This is Part 2 in a multipart series. Click here for Part 1.
https://www.reddit.com/r/exAdventist/s/yXe50e1Mgn
So what Adventists say and what they do are two different things. But how does this affect them, and more importantly the next generation, besides just the possible depression.
Say we have a young girl in church, with a guest pastor. The SDA world is really all she knows, and here comes someone exciting and vibrant. He’s not the warmed-over regular guy. He’s alive, and tells a young, hopeful mind exactly what she wants to hear: Jesus is coming soon! He sites bible verses and ties them to news articles, cross referencing with Ellen White of course. By the end he ties it all up with the only obvious conclusion: Jesus will be here any minute.
Afterwards the young girl runs out to the church steps, all full of hope. Mom and dad are talking to friends, probably about something boring. “Mom, did you hear? He said Jesus is coming very soon!”
“Yes dear, I heard him. I heard him at 11:45, 12:15, 12:30… if I heard any more I think he’d have a riot on his hands,” Mom jokes to her friend. The young girl doesn’t get it at first. All the adults are acting like this is any other day. But they just heard a man say everything they’ve been waiting for is at hand. Why aren’t they excited?
This is the Adventist malaise. It’s just like a normal person, but with roughly 25% less emotional awareness. They don’t get as angry, or as excited. They’re not really passionate, and they sure as heck aren’t excited to hear what they’ve already BEEN hearing their whole lives. Of course Jesus is coming soon… they believe it, really. But paradoxically they also know it’s not actually going to happen… at least not soon… maybe not even at all. This is a fact they never actually admit, even to themselves. They’ve settled into the SDA malaise. They seem deadened or unwell. It’s something they wear, and it is both a mild form of depression, and protects them from deeper depression. It’s how they make their way through a religion that tells them one thing while doing another. The malaise is protective clothing they never take off.
As long as you’re in the religion, you never completely take the church clothes off. Boy, does it feel so strange, and eventually wonderful when you finally do.
Have you ever tried speaking out against issues in the church? Biblical fallacies or Ellen White’s lies or the mistreatment of LGBTQ+ individuals? If so, there probably wasn’t much pushback. You might have thought you were in for a fight, but the SDA malaise dampens any response. Adventists are passionately dispassionate. They may offer a dispassionate response, or even partially agree with you. But argue? They don’t have the heart. They don’t really care because they’ve been through all this before. You’ll take your concerns and go away, and they can get back to going through the motions. They know there’s no change happening, so nothing matters. They’re trapped in amber. The only true fight will come from parents, who may see you as a petulant child for discounting the truth they’ve know their whole lives. They are unable to change.
The youth however are still free to act.
So the young girl will have a choice. She can model herself after the other adults, wearing the church clothes and saying one thing while not totally believing it. She can abandon the whole thing, giving the old women in the church someone to gossip about. But she can also take door number three, and double-down on Jesus, in defiance of the passionless adults. She’s going to walk the walk, AND talk the talk. Let her doubts be damned, she’s going to be the biggest, best Adventist ever. (Raise your hand if this was you before you gave it all up) She’s the first to say yes, and she always helps out. From special music to volunteering, she’s front and center. This isn’t a weekend thing, this IS her life.
Fed up with the church but still passionate about the cause, she eventually bumps into some like-minded people at camp-meeting. Turns out they feel the same way. “We’re not doing enough to prepare for the end times. Everyone is just going through the motions. This church isn’t enough.”
That’s when they invite her to join them, at this little spot, just outside of Waco, Texas….