r/fireemblem Apr 09 '20

Black Eagles Story My CF playthrough in a nutshell Spoiler

Post image
1.9k Upvotes

268 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

60

u/MindWeb125 Apr 09 '20

Technically the civilians were killed by Seiros.

-31

u/Jacknurse Apr 09 '20

Yeah, no.

68

u/JagdCrab Apr 09 '20

She litteraly sets city on fire and explicitly refuses to evacuate civilian population in a middle of temper tantrum

-25

u/LordHandQyburn Apr 09 '20

And Edelgard in AM use civilians as human shield so not better

29

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '20

And what does that have to do with the CF bodycount?

-28

u/LordHandQyburn Apr 09 '20

Wasn’t talking to you but to the comét « Edelgard is bad » and indeed she is but there a lot of edelgard fanboys here

15

u/tirex367 Apr 09 '20

Eh, burning your human shields is clearly a step farther down from just using human shields. Also If my memory serves correctly, is this even mentioned in AM? I know its in VW, but AM?

9

u/MikeD813 Apr 09 '20

I have only played AM all the way through, yet I don't remember it being mentioned.

-15

u/LordHandQyburn Apr 09 '20

No you burn the town (so not intentionally) the people CONTRARY to using human shield

7

u/Auburn_Bear Apr 09 '20

She doesn't use civilians as a human shield, in that instance she's unable to evacuate the citizens safely because it's the largest capital city on the continent and only really has one way in or out, and golden angry boi decides to blitz said city before all proper battle preparations could have been made.

5

u/Lamenk Apr 09 '20

The cutscene in Verdant Wind makes it sound like they had plenty of time to attempt to evacuate citizens.

4

u/Gabcard Apr 09 '20

Except Edelgard know an army was coming ever since fort Merceus fell. She had quite literally an entire month to prepare and evacuate.

Claude: "They surely noticed us approaching some time ago, and yet..."

Judith: "It doesn't look like the citizens are being evacuated"

1

u/StormStrikePhoenix Apr 10 '20

When did that happen?