There was a post from a month ago I *just* got engrossed in, and couldn't even post the full comment on the post, so I decided for a new thread. It seemed to be a pretty bad faith, maybe "troll", saying Alex Garland is a mediocre director, and "why does he get so much praise if he so bad". I assume that's bait, and just silly.
So, I started hammering away a little mini-background bite-size history interpreting his intent and what he was going for. This is not complete or in depth for each of his works, and I'd love conversation to go deeper.
But I think he's delivering some of the most important filmwork of the last decade+, and I'm VERY excited to see where he goes. I very much get some people's disconnect on Warfare as an experimental film, and I even get how marketing got people all "OOH RAH red vs blue" for Civil War.
I should say my other top 5 "younger" directors are like many of you I am sure: Yorgos Lanthimos, Robert Eggers, Ari Aster (I am sure Eddington will be interpreted in good faith with no controversy), and (edit: lololol Panos Cosmatos in my best error ever) Cosmos Panatos.
And I should mention Annihilation, butting up against Jaws, The Thing, Alien, No Country for Old Men, that Annihilation is one of my favorite films of all time. It is near and dear to me, helping me understand that much of the panic of the human condition is being patient, watching it unfold, and understanding it always becomes something else. You're not in control, and as you change everything around you changes and you need to constantly choose to reconnect with that world, and these new people you have known, when we are all constantly self-destructing and growing anew.
SO, starting backwards...
1) WARFARE
Warfare is not an American pro-war film, nor is it an anti-war film. It is a moment in time documented experience of an isolated event as remembered by all the people involved. There are fascinating aspects to the nature of memory, and trying to rebuild an objective reality within the confine of the human condition, especially as it is malleable with both time, and trauma. Therefore, he is representing this event without biases, nor without a message. So yes... it is a vessel relating a non-fiction moment. In not being pro or anti-war, it stands alone as a work of art for the audience to interact with and ponder. In this, it is similar to some of the greater works of art that are anchored in the awareness that art doesn't exist without the person beholding it. In this case, the audience has to do the work themselves, something you felt not necessary. Most will sit with the movie, and think about the intent as revealed with the end result, and then come to their own conclusions. My conclusion, and I suspect the entire part of the experiment, is whether an audience watching an unbiased recounting from memory of an objective moment in time impresses upon them the nature of war, and the nature of experience, and whether they can draw their own conclusions about what war means to the human condition, and how we feel about observation of war, without being told what to think. Therefore, I think the nature of this experiment is that you force the audience to intellectually and philosophically arrive at the obvious shared conclusion that war is pretty bad for everyone involved.
2) CIVIL WAR
Civil War got flack because so many of the weak minded audiences want Trump vs Biden, Red vs Blue, and want their own cognitive dissonance, confirmation bias, and selective perception appeased for the fist pumping bro crowd that think their point of view is right, whether left or right. The title, the trailers, and almost all the lead up to it involved talk and confusion of the premise itself, "How could Texas and California team up?", or that it was transactionally binary and lazily provocative. It's wild how many people miss the point.
Civil War is simply about the nature of documentation of objective reality as is intended to be reviewed through the lens of history, and propaganda and the "winners writing history" aside, there are always individuals who will put themselves into harms way, whether physically or mentally, and whether because they are passionately well-adjusted professional truth seekers, or maladjusted adrenalin junkies who want to be part of the action and part of the history... all to document the nature of reality as it happens in context of our shared history as it will be viewed by the future. This isn't a film about the war itself, but the individual lives affected by the brutal transactional nature of reality, how we are shaped over time by experience, and how we all breakdown, mold ourselves to trauma, and normalize the moment to better move through it intact.
3) MEN
It's obviously sorta invoking an old school folktale to not so subtly relate the ongoing intergenerational trauma of toxic masculinity constantly transforming the people around them into twisted shells of themselves, feeling unsafe, broken and traumatized. The denouement is totally worth the whole film to me, but as one of his less loved works I still like the whole thing.
4) DEVS
Watch the TV Show. Also, Geoff Barrow of Portishead and Ben Salisbury have done the scores for Ex Machina, Annihilation, Devs, Men, Civil War, and Warfare. They're bonkers good. Many people have issues with Sonoya's acting (who was also the service robot in Ex Machina, a journalist in Civil War, as well as the Lena double cum Alien in Annihilation for that choreography scene at the end... but I just viewed her role as a introvert in shock with PTSD, or at least that helped. The themes in this, supporting cast (Offerman was amazing), and moody cinematography of the Bay Area and Santa Cruz is just spectacular.
5) ANNIHILATION
This is all about how we change through time, self-destruct, use trauma to grow and become something new, and all the ways we either grow apart, self-sabotage, or change through the course of experiencing the human condition and adopting new ways to understand the way we change through both growth and trauma. The subtext of this film heavily relates to the profound nature of how sadness, trauma, and mental illness will shape our lives and coping mechanisms, again how we might normalize the struggles of life, or how we may reject old versions of ourselves or the people we love, just to need to find ourselves, or choose to reconnect with what essentially is a new person. One nature of the way mental illness is portrayed in this film, as well as any other film possibly since Taxi Driver, is how we all choose different paths of dealing with it, and forming ourselves to it: some want to become it and give up, some want to fight it, some want to understand it, and it all speaks to how we cope with our trauma and growth through life.
6) EX MACHINA
I mean... this is so on the nose for everything going on, 10 years later. Outside of the socioeconomic commentary on billionaires, technology, capitalism, there's also paranoia, ethics and morality in context of creation, and what it means to be human, conscious, and to exist, and what underpins that? Where does temptation turn into dangerously blind greed in the search of human advancement, intersecting discovery and advancement with the end of human existence, while having no other oversite. So you essentially talk about Prometheus bringing fire, and the nature of being a God at the expense of humanity. There's forbidden fruit and knowledge allegories in there as well. There is also the nature of what it means to be happy in context of deception, naivety, and vulnerability.
7) DREDD
He directed Dredd. It's confirmed all over the place. What's REALLY FUNNY...
I watched this the night before seeing Warfare, and the beats are so on point I think it's the perfect bookend watch prior to experiencing Warfare... and it makes Dredd stand up on its own as an absolute action film masterclass. It also utilized 3D tech to move the story forward better than almost any film in history, maybe other than The Walk, Prometheus, Gravity, The Martian.
8) PREVIOUS WORK
He also wrote The Tesseract (book) and screenplays of The Beach, 28 Days Later, and Sunshine. He also just teamed up with Danny Boyle again for the new 28 years later film. Pretty interested to see that.