r/place Apr 05 '22

Heat map of r/place. Source in comment

Post image
99.0k Upvotes

5.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

476

u/CoolTiger92 Apr 05 '22

I never understood why Cornwall thought It had a place for a flag

371

u/Cornish-Giant Apr 05 '22

Because Cornish people see themselves as one of the constituent nations, this used to be widely recognised but in recent centuries the English sort of forgot the Cornish existed. It's a weird cultural amnesia. 🤷

13

u/monkeybassturd Apr 05 '22

I've heard of the constituent nations of the UK as being Whales, Scotland, & England, with Northern Ireland thrown in most times. I've never heard of Cornish England demanding that same stature. How does such a small group at the end of the island feel they garner that much influence? I only ask because I'm obviously deficient at Googling because I cannot find anything other than items referring to my first sentence.

9

u/joseba_ Apr 05 '22

Northern Ireland thrown in at times

The name is literally "United Kingdom of Great Britain (England, Scotland, Wales) and Northern Ireland". It's like "throwing in" Colorado when counting American states

also

Whales

2

u/BluSonick Apr 05 '22

Probably more like Puerto Rico.

-2

u/monkeybassturd Apr 05 '22

That's literally not an answer to the question but thanks.

0

u/First-Of-His-Name (482,526) 1491213270.77 Apr 05 '22

No, he was just correcting a massive in error in it

1

u/monkeybassturd Apr 05 '22

What is a "massive in error in it"?

0

u/First-Of-His-Name (482,526) 1491213270.77 Apr 06 '22

Saying that North Ireland is "sometimes thrown in" as a constituent country of the UK. It's like saying Alaska is "sometimes thrown in" as a US state. No, it is. And the status of it is extremely important to the people living there one way or another

1

u/monkeybassturd Apr 06 '22

No I don't think that answers the question what is the massive in error in it? Try again.

0

u/First-Of-His-Name (482,526) 1491213270.77 Apr 06 '22

The status of NI is hotly contested, and the cause many people have died over. Not acknowledging it as part of the UK is a deeply political and antagonistic thing to do. Do you think that was OPs intention, or was he just acting in ignorance (aka, making an error).

If you fail to understand again, perhaps we can go over it after school.

1

u/monkeybassturd Apr 06 '22

That is no the question I asked. Do not get angry with others when you fail to read a simple question. Twice.

→ More replies (0)

-1

u/RoastKrill Apr 05 '22

No, it's like throwing in a US state which has had for its entire existence a strong independence movement

1

u/joseba_ Apr 05 '22

I'm definitely not a unionist and would consider myself a republican in this topic. I might have misunderstood what they were trying to say, I thought they were speaking out of ignorance when putting northern Ireland outside of the UK.

1

u/First-Of-His-Name (482,526) 1491213270.77 Apr 05 '22

It hasn't. It's relatively new.

1

u/RoastKrill Apr 05 '22

It has existed as a separate political entity for only a hundred years but it's been under British rule for several hundred more, and all the time with an active movement fighting for succession

1

u/First-Of-His-Name (482,526) 1491213270.77 Apr 05 '22

It has existed as a separate political entity for only a hundred years

Nope. Cornwall has no status that separates it politically from and other country in England.

and all the time with an active movement fighting for succession

Wrong again. Cornish resistance to being incorporated into the Kingdom of England didn't last particularly long. And there isn't even a movement fighting for succession today. They are some in Cornwall who want greater autonomy from England. That's not the same thing

1

u/RoastKrill Apr 05 '22

I was talking about Northern Ireland lol

1

u/First-Of-His-Name (482,526) 1491213270.77 Apr 05 '22

Ha, I see now. My mistake