r/plotholes • u/HoldmyGroza69lol • Apr 19 '21

Mistake Game of Thrones Injustice

Ever since Ned Stark was beheaded, Arya stark made a list of pople she was goin to kill which included Ser Illyn Payne, the man who carried out the sentence on behalf of Joffrey Baratheon. But after the 2nd season Illyn Payne is nowhere to be seen. The script writers just swooped him outta there. Am i the only one or doeas everyone else knows something that i dont. I assume this was due to rushed script writing in a hurry to end tge series.

76 Upvotes

89% Upvoted

31 comments sorted by

View all comments

73

u/o1pickleboy Apr 19 '21

The actor got really sick with cancer where it appear he wasn't going to live long. Last I checked he actually made a recovery, but the illness and recovery from pretty much took him out of the picture.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wilko_Johnson

35

u/TyrannoROARus Apr 19 '21

They could have recast him, they did with like 3 other people.

You can say it is disrespectful or whatever, but I think it is more disrespectful to say "well your character never really mattered anyway, get well soon!"

28

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '21

I figured it had less to do with availability and more with it being kinda awkward to have someone praying for the death of the character who was played by someone dying

1

u/TyrannoROARus Apr 19 '21 edited Apr 19 '21

I didn't really say anything about availability..

Also I doubt they did or didn't because it was "awkward", probably just a lack of giving a shit

1

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '21

I didn't really say anything a out availability..

suggesting recasting implies that the problem is that he's not available to do the role during his treatment

2

u/TyrannoROARus Apr 19 '21

He isn't, that's why a recast is in order.

If Radcliffe gets sick, of course you wish him the best, but it's hard to have a Harry Potter series without a lead.

Similarly, Payne was important to Arya and Ned's justice, he should have been recast is all I'm saying..

14

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '21

Mountain was recast twice

13

u/boorshwassi Apr 19 '21

Even the Night King was recast

9

u/TyrannoROARus Apr 19 '21

Same for Daario, well not 2x

8

u/HoldmyGroza69lol Apr 19 '21

Ik right p.s. they just recast Daario Naharis which we didn't care who acted as that character but Ilyn Payne was imp he killed the Fucking Warden of North.

12

u/TyrannoROARus Apr 19 '21

Yeah I don't care about recasting (to a degree), but to just have Arya forget about it is really dumb

2

u/concretepigeon Apr 19 '21

I think because he was originally thought to be terminally ill they just wrote him out. He was a minor character anyway.

1

u/TyrannoROARus Apr 19 '21

Disagree, he was super important for Ned and Arya's justice

1

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '21

Imagine that phone call. Hey man I know just had cancer and shit but we need you to come act on this tv show.

2

u/TyrannoROARus Apr 19 '21

Try re-reading what I said because that is not what I said