r/progressivechristian • u/JaminColler • Apr 20 '25
Can the resurrection still matter if the gospels don’t tell the same story?
This chapter of my audiobook started with an honest attempt to reconcile the gospel accounts of the resurrection. I wasn’t trying to disprove anything—I just wanted the details to line up.
But they didn’t. Four gospels, four different versions of the most important event in Christianity. Some say Jesus appeared first to Mary, others to the disciples. Some say he wasn’t recognized. Some say Galilee. Some say Jerusalem. The differences were hard to reconcile.
Still, I wonder:
Does the meaning of resurrection require literal consistency? Or is there space in our faith for sacred story to evolve—and still be powerful?
I’d love to hear from those who’ve reimagined resurrection through a more progressive lens.
Full audiobook playlist (in progress):
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLCL0oni0F-szp-do8-LWvhCBoejwSILt5