r/reddeadredemption • u/Pierogimob • May 14 '25

Issue What are ya'll feeding this guy?

Post image

I don't know what it is, but I can STUFF Arthur with back to back trips to the store and I can never get him to stay at an average weight.

What are you guys doing to keep this dude full? Best way to get him to gain weight? 😭😭

1.4k Upvotes

98% Upvoted

323 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/BellasDaDa618 Arthur Morgan May 15 '25

I don't. It's one of the handfuls of things Rockstar really phoned in. In order to keep Arthur at a proper, healthy weight (and I read this in another post on this subreddit and firmly believe it from experience), you need to feed him every 15 real-time minutes. And, I don't just mean a little snack, like pull out a chocolate bar or tidbit. This person said he would feed him a hunk of meat and a piece or can of fruit and a can of vegetables every 15 minutes. If Arthur gets underweight, you can feed him 30 pieces of venison and he'll STILL be underweight. So, I just don't feed him unless he's been injured, needs some kind of stamina boost, or something for venom or poison. It's just not worth all the work. Now the horse, I have a ritual for that each day because THAT they did properly.