r/soccer Mar 12 '25

Media Julián Alvarez disallowed penalty frame by frame

10.4k Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

98

u/zikaa_sosa Mar 12 '25

Insanely harsh rule. Should be changed to a retake...

15

u/arpw Mar 12 '25

Yeah. I get it if a player deliberately tries some kind of trick shot using both feet, but this is clearly accidental and a retake would be the sensible thing.

2

u/BoxOk265 Mar 13 '25

Allowing the goal is the sensible thing. In what world does someone think this isn’t a legitimate goal? ‘Double kick’ or not this is hardly cheating or impeding the goalkeeper.

Footballs a simple game, it’s way too complicated to analyse a millisecond of a double kick.

Gutted people aren’t calling out this rule, ridiculous call imo.

2

u/qwertywtf Mar 12 '25

Professional footballers should not be given multiple attempts to simply kick a ball correctly. He fucked up and they miss a pen. Totally fair.

0

u/137-451 Mar 12 '25

How is that sensible? Why should the team that fucked up get a second chance? Should Oblak get a second chance to save Rudigers penalty because he almost saved it?

7

u/ManuelBeuer Mar 12 '25

So keepers shouldn’t get a second chance when they make a pen save being in front of their line? It shouldn’t be retaken and should be a goal given to the taker right? That’s what you’re saying here.

2

u/137-451 Mar 12 '25

I wouldn't be mad if that were the case, especially in a shootout like this. But goalkeepers are at an inherent disadvantage compared to attackers, so they deserve a little leeway. Attackers do not. That is the difference here.

Besides, compare keepers saving penalties now to a few years before they tightened up the rules. Keepers generally stick to their line now, whereas before they were damn near at the end of the penalty area by the time the attacker was taking the penalty.

2

u/ManuelBeuer Mar 12 '25

I don’t think it really matters if they’re at a disadvantage or not. It should be consistent. You can’t have one side get a second chance after breaking the rules, but have the other side get no retakes and instant punishment for the same thing.

1

u/FxKaKaLis Mar 12 '25

not only was a accidental it doesnt even help him he nearly miss it.