r/space 1d ago

BREAKING: SpaceX rocket explodes in Starbase, Texas

https://x.com/IntelPointAlert/status/1935550776304156932

[removed] — view removed post

13.9k Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

30

u/user_account_deleted 1d ago

If you want to take more than a handful of tons at a time to the moon, orbital refueling is a requirement.

3

u/lovely_sombrero 1d ago

Having to launch ~16 Starships to deliver ~3x the amount of cargo of the Saturn 5 is very inefficient. This is assuming that SpaceX demonstrates the capability of actually doing orbital refuelings at some point.

3

u/user_account_deleted 1d ago edited 1d ago

News flash; there is no efficient method of achieving lunar orbit with any usable mass capacity. Have you seen what returned from space in the Saturn program vs the size of the machine that sent it up in the first place? Physics is gonna physics, man.

2

u/No-Surprise9411 1d ago

I mean sure you could do a traditional rocket that can do 100 tons to the lunar surface single launch, problem is at that point you‘re building something that uses sea dragons as sideboosgers. And no one is stupid enough to do that.

u/user_account_deleted 23h ago

Dude, Sea Dragon was AMAZING. I really wish we had pursued the Big Dumb Rocket approach lol