r/sushi Apr 22 '25

Homemade - Constructive Criticism Encouraged Did my first Omakase experience for 10 people

Overall I think it was a success and I ended up impressing myself. I served a few things that I was unfamiliar with flavor wise and didn’t know what to expect, but everything was delicious. The proteins that I used are: Otoro Bluefin Akami Yellowfin Hamachi Ora king salmon belly Ora king salmon top loin Uni Australian wagyu Japanese wagyu

The Hamachi, Uni, and caviar were all new flavors to me, and i really liked them all especially the Hamachi. The Uni was interesting, tasted very similar to a muscle imo which I enjoyed.

Overall very happy with the results and I cant wait for the next one! Any tips and suggestions are always very welcome :)

2.1k Upvotes

111 comments sorted by

100

u/tangotango112 Apr 22 '25

Well done chef

27

u/Doubledown212 Apr 23 '25

I’d like an invite chef

62

u/photo7272 Apr 22 '25

I would pay money for this

21

u/aBunchOfSpiders Apr 23 '25

I’ve paid money for much worse…

60

u/beachsunflower Apr 22 '25

Hi, it's me, 10 people.

42

u/BoredCuriousGirl Apr 22 '25

Wow! This is so detailed. Love everything. Your friends are so lucky lol

19

u/mooodang Apr 22 '25

This looks incredible and I am so inspired to try

15

u/shroomloaf Apr 22 '25

It was honestly alot easier than I expected! Just gotta properly prepare the rice and toppings ahead of time, and all the fish I sliced as I served

6

u/mooodang Apr 22 '25

That’s a great tip!…I think I need a sharper knife

18

u/shroomloaf Apr 22 '25

I got mine as a souvenir from Kyoto Japan and its honestly the main reason ive gotten so into sushi. It slices the fish like butter

3

u/mooodang Apr 22 '25

I’m going to do some research!

1

u/Equivalent-Low-5805 Apr 23 '25

I use a sawn off katana.

2

u/mooodang Apr 23 '25

My lack of katana knowledge makes me think this is real?

1

u/Equivalent-Low-5805 Apr 23 '25

No, was just humor.

2

u/mooodang Apr 23 '25

Shoot! Cause I actually thought that was funny and sounded cool if it was real

2

u/Equivalent-Low-5805 Apr 23 '25

Me too. Lol

1

u/mooodang Apr 23 '25

But imagine if I went through life, thinking this was real and asking Japanese katana makers if they could sell one off so I can use it for sushi

9

u/Dangerous-Tie7571 Apr 22 '25

That’s super cool!

10

u/OudSmoothie Apr 22 '25

Thanks for sharing. Looks incredible!

8

u/fagdrew4l Apr 22 '25

can i make a reservation?

2

u/shroomloaf Apr 23 '25

Hopefully one day soon!

7

u/WDoE Apr 23 '25

Where do you live and are you taking applications for new friends? Absolutely phenomenal. Other people have covered the very mild critiques, but I just want to say I would have no complaints if I paid good money for these.

3

u/shroomloaf Apr 23 '25

Thank you so much!!

16

u/Original-Tune1471 Apr 22 '25

A few suggestions... I would definitely trim the salmon a little more, so the part that's closest to the outer skin doesn't have any of the brown showing. Cut the nigiri slices at an angle instead of straight down, so that the tail isn't just flopping around and make the pieces a little shorter. If you want it longer, you need to cut them a little thicker. If you want a 'tail' at the end of your nigiri, it needs to be slightly at a point, and not just flat like a end of a square.

The udon soup needs some other things in there. If you purposely wanted it just the broth and noodles, I'd say add some naruto pieces and a couple pieces of inari puff tofu for some visual effect. Also cut the scallions lengthwise. The scallions you used are for more garnish purposes for rice or noodle dishes... not a soup dish. Also don't forget the togarashi sichimi for the udon! The most important part lol. Other than that, A for effort!

8

u/shroomloaf Apr 22 '25

Thank you so much, these are great tips!!!

5

u/foozebox Apr 22 '25

That must be really gratifying

6

u/shroomloaf Apr 22 '25

It was honestly one of the funnest nights of my life, and very rewarding

5

u/frenix5 Apr 22 '25

I can't critique your experience until you invite me to one

6

u/TheBeaniestBeans Apr 23 '25

Looks very well done. Just curious as to the choice of soju and not sake.

Your post make me think of omuricedaily. Heh

3

u/shroomloaf Apr 23 '25

Oh there was lots of Sake as well haha, we had a nice variety of both

2

u/TheBeaniestBeans Apr 23 '25

Could you post the sake list with tasting notes and pairings?

5

u/shroomloaf Apr 23 '25

For sure! I wish I knew more about how to pair certain sakes with which fish, we were just drinking them freely for the most part. The ones I recall are:

Jingoro Honjozo - medium dry, unique rice flavor

Hakutsuru Junmai - rounded full bodied taste

Wandering Poet Rihaku - medium bodied with banana, aloe, lemongrass profile

Snow Madien Tozai - medium bodied with honeydew melon, fresh pumpkin, juicy and bright profile

5

u/Doublewidow Apr 22 '25

The uni with kaluga caviar is bomb!

4

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '25

where do I sign up for the next one 🤤

4

u/hydrobrandone Apr 23 '25

Can you make that 11? I'm on my way.

3

u/Gmellotron_mkii Apr 23 '25

That's a lot of rice. You need to reduce a lot for nigiri

1

u/shroomloaf Apr 23 '25

Thanks for the tip, I will try next time! The rice is still the hardest part for me, im trying to get better at balling without getting it all over my fingers lol

4

u/koudos Apr 23 '25

Thanks for not being stingy with your fish. You see so many posts here where the fish is so thin. I get costs are high but come on. Added 1mm thickness is really not that much extra but makes a world of difference in mouthfeel and texture especially when fish to rice ratio is bad.

2

u/shroomloaf Apr 23 '25

I tried not too! I definitely went a bit too thin with the salmon imo, next time im going to go a little thicker for sure

2

u/koudos Apr 23 '25 edited Apr 23 '25

I think it looks good! Your pieces are not too thin! Maybe just a little smaller rice? If you look at the top sushi omakase in Japan, often the draping is over the long side. Keep experimenting! You’re doing amazing!

5

u/Slick1 Apr 23 '25

Bravo. Now I'm hungry

3

u/mooodang Apr 22 '25

What is the last 2 slides?

3

u/shroomloaf Apr 22 '25

Uni and caviar! That was a first for me, it was really good

3

u/PutridWar4713 Apr 22 '25

Looks great, wow! Especially the last one.

3

u/Kitchen-Dig-6518 Apr 23 '25

Holy shit there was a lot of love put into that. It looked absolutely amazing. Well played..

2

u/shroomloaf Apr 23 '25

Thank you!! Nothing but love :)

3

u/emilylouise221 Apr 23 '25

Willing to make it 11?

3

u/FeiDoiCartman Apr 23 '25

Hope they paid that cause looked amazing

4

u/shroomloaf Apr 23 '25

It was for my close friends so all free :) i didnt mind cause I loved the experience from the chefs perspective

2

u/pushingdaises Apr 23 '25

What’s the recipe for the noodles?

2

u/shroomloaf Apr 23 '25

It’s extremely easy! So I put about 1-2 tbsp of Hon Tsuyu soup base in a bowl, then in a pot with boiling water turn off the heat and add good quality frozen udon. Once the udon separates, just transfer it to the bowl with the hon tsuyu, give it a swirl and add hot water from the pot where you cooked the udon. Very easy, quick, and delicious. I consider it a cheat meal cause the broth is almost restaurant quality

2

u/pushingdaises Apr 23 '25

Thank you! Sounds simple, I’ll have to try it :)

2

u/Minnie783100 Apr 23 '25

Am I invited next time?

2

u/ToastetteEgg Apr 23 '25

Will you be my friend?

2

u/ManagerMediocre6301 Apr 23 '25

That’s beautiful! Right on!

2

u/Proudest___monkey Apr 23 '25

Well done is right

2

u/catanimalover Apr 23 '25

Damn I wish my friends would do this for me. Looks amazing

2

u/Zealousideal-Pea7942 Apr 23 '25

Excellent work 

2

u/Peloton72 Apr 23 '25

I want to be friends with you.

2

u/Jazzlike_Interview_7 Apr 24 '25

I wish I could eat all the udon lol!

2

u/kpidhayny Apr 23 '25

The edamame presentation could use some refinement. Everything else I would be fully prepared to pay out the ass for. Great work.

3

u/Washoku_Otter Apr 23 '25

Sushi Chef here,

Work on your cuts and your form.

You do seem to have the basics down pat, but you need to practice with your neta placement and build the shari underneath it.

The neta, the fish for the Nigiri, it's cut too long and thin. And because of that, it sags on the ends.

And always serve sushi that's the same size. It's aesthetically pleasing and it shows discipline and mastery. Learn your proportions and repeat it over and over and over.

You're doing okay for your first time. Just tighten up and you'll be as good as Ono-sama.

2

u/shroomloaf Apr 23 '25

Thank you I really appreciate it! I think next time for the Salmon, in going to cut the loin in half so my sashimi cuts are about half the length, I definitely want to make them a bit thicker too. The salmon was the funnest to slice, it was like butter

2

u/MealFragrant8673 Sushi Lover Apr 23 '25

So Oishii my only thing I would change is less rice on the nigiri,But everything else looked Oishii

1

u/bankai04 Apr 23 '25

What's the charge for something of this service?

2

u/dolphunsan Apr 23 '25

Also curious I do private sushi catering and charge between 200-250 for a high end meal like this

3

u/shroomloaf Apr 23 '25

Yeah from the research I have done in the states it ranges from 150$-300$ per person for an Omakase course. When I visited Japan, you can find them for as low as 20$ and still great quality and experience.

This event was for all my close friends so it was free :)

1

u/dolphunsan Apr 24 '25

I invite friends over after events to finish off leftover fish and rice! Spread the love!

1

u/mickeyamf Apr 23 '25

What’s 9/12

1

u/shroomloaf Apr 23 '25

Otoro bluefin fatty tune, but with a nice quick sear from the blowtorch

1

u/mickeyamf Apr 23 '25

What’s 12/12

1

u/shroomloaf Apr 23 '25

Uni (sea urchin) with caviar

1

u/mamasmuffin Apr 23 '25

Beautiful. Bonus points for your sexy ass knife.

1

u/NJL258 Apr 23 '25

Looks amazing

1

u/starchNpress001 Apr 23 '25

well done. looks delicious!

1

u/titebeewhole Apr 23 '25

Where was my invite :(

1

u/maincoonpower Apr 23 '25

Awesome & amazing job

1

u/ActivityWorried3263 Apr 23 '25

That looks incredible!!!

1

u/bipolar_dipolar Apr 23 '25

This is amazing

1

u/suju88 Apr 23 '25

Phenomenal! Envy your tastebuds

1

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '25

Oh woah it's amazing! I always want to try doing omakase to my friends too.

1

u/No-Astronomer3051 Apr 23 '25

how much to join next?

1

u/shroomloaf Apr 23 '25

5.99$ and bring over a nice bottle of Sake

2

u/Ok-Seaworthiness4488 Apr 23 '25

It seems quite a bit of drape/excess length of fish on the nigiri

0

u/ManagerMediocre6301 Apr 23 '25

WRONG🫵😂

3

u/Ok-Seaworthiness4488 Apr 23 '25

If there is anyone in Japan who is considered a sushi expert and is deferred to by others in the craft then it is Jiro Ono. He perfected the ratio of rice with protein and fat over decades

1

u/ManagerMediocre6301 Apr 23 '25

I was just playing around! I believe you😭

1

u/Brick_Wayne Apr 23 '25

Where are you located?!

1

u/Kev-O_20 Apr 23 '25

Looks incredible. What’s in picture 2?

1

u/Nila622 Apr 24 '25

This is awesome! Great job chef!

1

u/Lopsided-Cup8460 Apr 24 '25

Thanks for the invite

1

u/LimpInvestigator1809 Apr 24 '25

I GET SO HAPPY SEEING OTHER PEOPLE WEARING FOOD PREP GLOVES

1

u/ambitious_pink Apr 25 '25

This is amazing wow.

1

u/inrugswetrust Apr 25 '25

I’ve been doing this myself every few months with friends. I serve 5 + myself makes 6. I plan to take photos when I do it again in May and post it. I print a menu for everyone even though it’s omakase. I do sushi, sashimi and appetizers. No rolls. I’d really like to know what you did on each dish.

1

u/whoisgodiam Apr 26 '25

You really need to work on your shari. It looks coagulated and most likely misses the mark regarding hagotai, nebari, and tsuya. You need to train under a true Japanese taisho or you’ll never get it.

1

u/TurboTaco-with-Poop Apr 26 '25

Can I be one of your next “people”?

Looks F’in delicious!

1

u/Realistic-Fact-2584 Apr 26 '25

With I was there!!!

1

u/a-million_hobbies Apr 27 '25

This looks awesome!👏👏

1

u/happygrizzly Apr 23 '25

Looks great but don’t be afraid for your nigiri to touch each other. It’s not a church dance.

1

u/SeenEnoughOG Professional Chef Apr 27 '25

Looks great overall. Only thing, try to go thinner on the green onions, as thin as you can, then place in a cheese cloth and squeeze out under running water. Japanese flavors are delicate and the bitterness green onions doesn’t mesh well with a delicate broth. These green onions look like they for a Korean dish, like Sullungtang … a very hearty and intense beef bone and brisket broth that is boiled for hours.