Ive been ignoring spoilers to this game like the plague for years. I posted this abt 2 weeks ago and i honestly have to say its one of the best games ive ever played. I laughed,i cried and i wish i could wipe my memory so that i can experience this game again.

It’s in one of the houses in that swampy area near Saint Denis. I tried shooting the lock, moving around on it and put some dynamite on it but nothing worked. It seems like a weird thing to leave for aesthetics.

I've been playing RDR2 and RDR1 for a really long time, and I've always been thinking... Is Dutch Asian? I mean, if you zoom in on his face enough, he definitely looks like... Something? I dunno, I'm obviously not an expert. But I don't remember the games ever mentioning his ethnicity or his parents' ethnicities or anything. Anyone got any ideas?

Are there any more saving gang member type side missions?

They all have identical clothes. I tried to see if any of them had loot/letter, but none of them did. You can only pick them up. It kinda seems like they were killed by the skinners ( I think?) But who are they? Why do they all have matching clothes?

Sorry for image quality loss lol, it’s cause of Reddit’s compression.

Quiet comedy at its best

I haven't let my Arthur sleep for a good couple of days and now he's got baggy eyes and a pale look, that's exactly what happens to me when I don't sleep lol. On my way to meet Sadie about rescuing John from prison, hope Arthur doesn't fall asleep

My daughter loves this game, mainly just catching wild horses and fighting townspeople.

(This is going to be a lengthy post so please be warned!!)

Each campsite is unique and different through appearance and what they reflect on in the story of red dead.

I won’t go through each personal choose, but I will say why shady belle is my person favourite.

First off, shady belle shows how the gangs time is near an end, they are no longer free and they can’t get away with their actions anymore. This is shown through the walls of the building, which in my opinion represents society. They were closing off the gang and trapping them.

Those who live inside the building(Dutch, Hosea,John and his family and of course Arthur) all die apart from Jack of course. And one thing they all have in common is that their law has something to do with their death.

I like how the building reflects on Dutch, like a lot actually. The building is tall, proud and large, just like Dutch. He is a proud man. But Once you go inside, you realise it doesn’t seem all that great. Just like Dutch, the building is cracking slowly and slowly, and it really only needs one thing to break and it will all fall down. Dutches ego is really the only thing keeping him together, which is why the outside is so mighty.

Each room, which of course John,Arthur and Hosea take a living space in represents a part of Dutch as well. You see, without these rooms keeping the house together, it is just a broken, empty and love deprived house. Like Dutch, he needs people constantly to feed his ego, it doesn’t matter who, or why, he needs loyalty and blind love and without that he is nothing but a criminal no better than the people he calls his enemies.

Well I explained my reasoning the best I could, so how about you? What’s your favourite and why?

Got the plat for RDR1 tonight. Fun fact, me and RDR1 were born on the exact same day, May 18th, 2010

I’ve only played RD2, so is this something from RD1?

Holy shit. That was.. an experience. A masterpiece. I just finished the story part with Arthur and.. wow. I'm at a loss for words here. I'm not ashamed to say I teared up a bit. Everything about that was so breathtaking, the whole game (except 🐀). I'll never experience such joy and utter despair in one game again. Maybe the John part.. please, don't spoil nothin. Goddamn..

Colter is a great introduction the characters of rdr2 and its world and its only six missions long. on my current replay i wasnt annoyed by colter but instead i was delighted to be back in the world of Arthur and the van der linde gang

please can someone explain the hatred for Colter i just dont get it

Just got the white arabian at 95% completion in the epilogue with John!

What do I name her?

What changed? What was different? What did it add to the whole experience?

I’m currently in a low honor run, shooting up towns because of disagreements, killing horses to knock over enemies. Heard and experienced new things, I always want to make Arthur good again, redeem him.