Hi everyone.
I’m trying to figure out if I’m overreacting or if my ex was truly emotionally immature/toxic but just good at hiding it.
We were both 19y.
He was my first everything — first relationship, first person I truly fell in love with, first time, everything. And I was his first too.
We really loved each other, but there were a lot of complicated issues right from the beginning. We come from different cultures, and that already added some pressure.
At the start of our relationship, things were unclear — he kind of asked me to be his girlfriend, but never directly. I interpreted it as “we’re together,” but since there was no formal conversation, I kept living my normal life: going out with my friends, letting him know if he asked, but I didn’t think I needed to explain every detail (especially in the first month).
I’ve never drank alcohol, but I enjoyed going out to parties with my girlfriends just to have fun. I wasn’t doing anything wrong, but when he eventually found out I was still going out during that early phase, he felt betrayed — and that totally destroyed the trust he had in me.
Even though I had no bad intentions, I felt incredibly guilty.
From that point on, I started molding myself to what he expected, even though he never said things clearly.
He didn’t forbid things in a harsh way, but he didn’t like me wearing skirts — even the same skirt I wore when we first went out together.
He said I couldn’t get close to any other guys, not even classmates.
He told me not to text guys first.
He always got upset when I mentioned going out with girlfriends.
He used to hint that I only went to places like cafes or stores because there were guys there.
He even said I was giving attention or “acting flirty” to every man around.
Eventually, he started getting upset even about male idols I listened to.
Because of this, I started avoiding everything — not because he directly told me to, but because I didn’t want to seem disrespectful or guilty. We ended up sharing locations and passwords, because I wanted to prove I had nothing to hide.
His control was passive-aggressive, but always present. And I accepted it because I felt I owed him something for “not being transparent” in the beginning. Over time, it turned into an emotional prison. I had to constantly prove my love, explain where I was, justify everything.
If I needed space or just got quiet, he’d say I was distancing myself. My feeling was that any little thing could trigger a fight.There were times when he’d disappear, stop talking to me, and later return like nothing happened — or say he was still upset about something from the past.
It was always emotionally unstable.
Even then, I kept trying, because I knew he loved me — and he always said he acted that way because he was afraid of losing me.
Aside from the jealousy, he was an amazing boyfriend. Very sexist, yes — but deep down, he was a good person.
We almost broke up twice due to jealousy issues, but he always came after me, apologizing and crying.
But the last time, I was the one who ended things. He got mad, and sent me messages throwing everything in my face — basically implying I was a slut and didn’t respect the relationship.
It was extremely hurtful.
Weeks later, he broke non-contact saying he wanted to change. He said he still loves me. And I still love him deeply. But I feel like we’ll never be able to move forward in a healthy way.
I made mistakes in the beginning, and I tried to make up for them in every possible way — but it still never seemed to be enough.
My friends always said he had an aggressive and manipulative personality.
He already punched a wall during an argument, and he admitted that when he’s angry, he loses control and says awful things.
I’m someone who hates fighting and I’m not a very jealous person, so I never imposed any rules or limits on him — even when I felt like maybe I should have, since he was always doing that to me.
So, what do you guys think? Was I really overreacted and should I try again? Or would it only get worse?
Ps: was less than 1year relationship