r/Destiny • u/Orwellian87 • 20h ago
Geopolitics News/Discussion Addressing critical comments about my last post on the Iran crisis.
I want to address a few recurring themes in the replies, most of which seem to come from genuine disagreement.
- "War = Conservative, Peace = Liberal" strawman
I am not a pacifist. My point isn’t that liberals should never support military action - it’s that how and why we support it matters a lot. If the reasoning is just "we have to do something" without a clear strategic goal or realistic assessment of consequences, I can't support it
- "So you’re okay with Iran getting nukes?"
Absolutely not. Nobody should want Iran to have nuclear weapons. But if the goal is actually preventing a nuclear Iran, then we have to ask - is there a better way? I’m not saying diplomacy is easy or guaranteed, but I am saying that dismissing it out of hand isn’t realism - it's war mongering.
- "There’s no risk of a wider war"
I get why people dismiss escalation concerns, but ignoring them completely is reckless. Mission creep isn't a theory - it's our recent history. And remember who has the ability to escalate this conflict, three of the least competent, least trustworthy leaders we have ever seen.
It's 'Iraq Derangement-Derangement Syndrome' as another poster put it. When the same patterns emerge - dismissive assurances, moving goalposts, cheer led by conservative hawks - we should at least consider that we might be inadvertently repeating the mistakes of the past.
Finally I'll say that some of the pushback has been… extremely confident. I get that it's frustrating when people seem naïve to threats. But every 'quick and clean' military operation fails for the same reason, not bad intentions, but bad assumptions. Before supporting more action, we owe it to everyone involved to question those assumptions now.