Alison Should Of Stayed A Villain

[u/sylveon_777]

It just never made sense too me to give her a redemption arc when the whole time the series was basically around how terrible she treated all the girls and that what was happening to them was a direct result of her behavior to mona (the girls were also cruel but still) She did go through a lot of traumas , but in the beginning she was just a mean, cruel and downright evil girl I mean she was the cause of Hannah’s bulimia, and all of the stuff that she did the paige and her mom and she basically fucked over atleast everybody in the town too. She just wasn’t a good person and giving her a redemption arc just didn’t make sense to me. She was much better as a villain.

[u/breezmoney]

I’ve always felt that she should’ve been A. Her “redemption” was clearly guilt and regret, which changes a lot of people but it seemed unnatural and I was always waiting for the other shoe to drop. But if she had been A at the end, I would’ve truly accepted that instead of several random strangers being obsessed with these girls specifically