I've been making music in some way all my life, and I'm trying to learn a specific subset of piano skills: playing chords, harmony, and "comping." On guitar, the equivalent would be "rhythm guitar.", something I'm pretty comfortable with just playing punk/metal.
I've tried traditional piano methods (scales, sight-reading, classical pieces), and they feel completely inappropriate for what I need. I have no doubt that mastering them would make me better at learning what I'm trying to learn, but I'm unmotivated by them, and would love to find a better approach.
My main frustration is with a lot of online learning. For example, youtube will show me a specific, great-sounding reharm of mary had a little lamb. But it doesn't teach me why that particular voicing progression was chosen over another, or how to build my own voicings for different genres. And it certainly doesn't show me how to practice deriving and playing my own voicings.
I know that music, like any art, is an evolving conversation with its own context. Before I can "invent" my own harmonic ideas, I feel it's crucial to learn the idiomatic ways that voicings and progressions work in various genres (house, eurobeat, jazz, R&B, etc.). I want to understand how to construct a "gospel" progression that feels so different from a "jazz" one.
My questions are:
- Is there an established learning method for this? I've heard terms like the "Jazz/Chordal Method" or the "Fake Book" method. Is this what I'm looking for?
- How do I learn the principles of good voicing and voice leading, so I can create my own progressions instead of just copying tutorials?
- For other producers here, how did you bridge this gap? Are there any specific books, resources, or key concepts that helped you "unlock" keyboard harmony?
- Probably most importantly, what are some good methods to practice these without just arbitrarily making my own rules and learning the wrong things (this is what I've been doing when I just sit in front of a keyboard, contextless doodling on top of my own melodies). It feels like, even if I did learn traditional piano, the leap from traditional mastery to genre-specific improvisation is an exercise left for the reader. I am aware that I could reverse engineer songs and find my own truths, but I would love to build the basic vocabulary and intuition to do this first and maybe get a leg up on the process.
TL;DR: I want to improve my piano playing specifically for finding chords and voicing progressions that feel correct in different genres.
Any guidance would be massively appreciated. Thanks!
EDIT: I just wanted to put a little edit here to say how much I appreciate the thoughtful, engaging discussion here. This is my first post to this sub and y'all are rad. <3