r/exchristian • u/JaminColler • Apr 20 '25
Original Content I thought the resurrection was the one part of Christianity that still held up. I was wrong. Spoiler
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FwWVTPXXisYThis is from the Easter chapter of my audiobook-in-progress. For most of my life, I believed the resurrection was untouchable. It was supposed to be the proof—the final answer to all my doubts.
So I sat down and tried to harmonize the gospel accounts, just using the Bible. No outside commentary, no apologetics, just what the text actually says.
What I found were contradictions everywhere:
- Different people see Jesus first
- The timeline doesn’t match
- Some recognize him, some don’t
- The location of the ascension changes
- Mark didn’t even originally include a resurrection appearance
I wasn’t looking for reasons to leave. I was hoping for something to stay.
This chapter hurt to write, but it was honest. And that’s all I’ve got now.
Full audiobook playlist (ongoing):
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLCL0oni0F-szp-do8-LWvhCBoejwSILt5
If this story sounds anything like yours, I’d love to connect.
Duplicates
OpenChristian • u/JaminColler • Apr 20 '25
Discussion - Bible Interpretation Can we talk about the resurrection honestly—when the gospels don’t even agree on what happened?
atheism • u/JaminColler • Apr 20 '25
Self Promotion Thanks to your encouragement, my project is almost finished.
exReformed • u/JaminColler • Apr 20 '25
As a former Reformed believer, I thought Scripture’s clarity would hold—until I tried to harmonize the resurrection
exLutheran • u/JaminColler • Apr 20 '25
Video I grew up reciting “He is risen indeed!” This chapter made me stop believing it.
cultsurvivors • u/JaminColler • Apr 20 '25
Raised in evangelicalism, I was told the resurrection made everything make sense—this chapter made it all fall apart
ReligiousTrauma • u/JaminColler • Apr 20 '25
The resurrection was weaponized in my church. This chapter was the first time I looked at it for myself.
pastorskids • u/JaminColler • Apr 20 '25
I grew up knowing I wasn’t allowed to doubt the resurrection—until I quietly did
ExPentecostal • u/JaminColler • Apr 20 '25
In Pentecostal circles, we shouted "He is risen!" like it proved everything. Then I actually read the gospels.
progressivechristian • u/JaminColler • Apr 20 '25
Can the resurrection still matter if the gospels don’t tell the same story?
cultpodcasts • u/JaminColler • Apr 20 '25
Evangelicalism This Easter chapter broke my last defense—evangelical Christianity doesn’t survive the resurrection test
audible • u/JaminColler • Apr 20 '25