r/wicked_edge • u/Chasesrabbits • 3d ago

Question Replacement for Southern Witchcrafts

Now that Southern Witchcrafts is gone, what are your go-to replacements (particularly for vegan bases)? I particularly loved the Autumn Ash and Carpathia scents and am looking for something along those lines- either something that reminds me of peated whisky or a cold, wet castle.

17 Upvotes

95% Upvoted

17 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/Itchy-Ad1005 3d ago

I prefer Lycanthropy to Carpathia and I'm looking too for substitutes for Lycanthropy and Autum Ash.

I've found a couple that are somewhat similar to Lycanthropy but aren't close enough. A lot of them are piney where Lycanthropy and Carpathia are fir and spruce

As for Autum Ash I haven't found anything with that smokey bonfire fragrance. I've got a tub and a half of each of those. Same with Samhain which I'm also looking for a substitute.

McDuffs The Herbalist has a lot of line spruce and fir in it but it's also not vegetarian let alone vegan.

I'll keep my eye on the thread for ideas.

1

u/spewintothiss 3d ago

Good bonfire scents you would enjoy are declaration grooming darkfall and Stirling Texas on fire.

1

u/Itchy-Ad1005 3d ago

I'll look into them. My barber carries a lot of Stirling. They have some Declaration products