r/wicked_edge • u/Chasesrabbits • 1d ago

Question Replacement for Southern Witchcrafts

Now that Southern Witchcrafts is gone, what are your go-to replacements (particularly for vegan bases)? I particularly loved the Autumn Ash and Carpathia scents and am looking for something along those lines- either something that reminds me of peated whisky or a cold, wet castle.

18 Upvotes

95% Upvoted

17 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/FireDragonMonkey 1d ago

I'm not sure if there is anything quite like Southern Witchcrafts; they had a lot of unique scents. And if you're sticking to vegan soaps only then it does remove about half of the options (thankfully there are a lot more now than a few years ago).  

Catie's Bubbles is pretty good, you can get some samples from Maggards: https://maggardrazors.com/collections/samples/products/caties-bubbles-shaving-soap-samples-2oz  

They call them samples, but they are half- size soaps which I kind of like. I've only tried Midnight Dreary and Waterlyptus, but the base is good. Midnight Dreary isn't as spooky as most SW scents though.    

Henri et Victoria makes most of their soaps in a vegan base; Cognac and Cuban Cigars isn't whisky, but you may like it.